StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Developmental Psychology of Gender Identity in Children - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Developmental Psychology of Gender Identity in Children" compares two theoretical approaches - psychodynamic theories and cognitive theories  - to understand the development of gender identity in kids. It evaluates the strength of their principles and supporting empirical evidence…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Developmental Psychology of Gender Identity in Children
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Developmental Psychology of Gender Identity in Children"

This paper will present the points of similarity as well as contrasts between the two theories. These theories are backed by empirical evidence received from some secondary sources.

The developmental psychology of gender identity in children can be learned from the psychodynamic theories and cognitive theories. Apart from these broad categories, other theories also have valid existence in this subject, which is based upon biological accounts, social learning, or cultural influence. However, those theories are beyond the scope of this paper and shall not be discussed here.

The Cognitive Theory
The Cognitive Theory emphasizes the role the child plays in the construction of its own identity through ‘self-socialization’. This implies that the child is guided by its own cognitive process to determine its own gender which governs its own behavior and judges the behaviors of its peers (McManus, 1999). According to Kohlberg, the problem of sexual development is not directly influenced by neither the biological features of a child nor the culture in which he is brought up. Sexual identity begins with cognition. In this context, one has to keep in mind the distinction between sex and gender. Sex is the physical attribute that a baby is born with while gender refers to the psychological, emotional as well as behavioral attributes that are associated with the particular group of same-sex members as the child.

Gender Schema Theory
According to the cognitive-developmental theory, children pass through “basic gender identity and gender stability” (Shaffer, 2009, p. 283) before they can reach gender consistency. At this point in time, the child becomes selective about persons of the same sex as it and become gender-typed. The Gender Schema Theory is a subpart of the cognitive theory. This theory, developed by Martin and Halverson, explains that a child, who has recognized a basic gender identity, establishing itself as boy or girl, builds “in-group/out-group” and own-sex gender schema”. These help the child to process any gender-related information also in associating itself with stereotyped gender roles. The child is guided by logic or reasoning on his own and the discovery of his own gender helps in the formation of a gender schema. Subsequently, other gender beliefs dawn upon him. This determines the child’s preferences for the choice of play toys and also peer groups. The child behaves in an appropriate way that is considered typical to its gender by accepting the schema's consistent information and discarding the schema's inconsistent ones (Shaffer, 2009, p. 283).

The Psychodynamic Theory
The psychodynamic theory goes back to its founder, Sigmund Freud. In general, this theory explains that “relationships within the family determine gender” (Bolich, 2007, p. 135). The principle of this theory is that children face inner psychic conflicts while they grow up, which are responsible for the identification of their gender and behavioral pattern. The masculine or feminine identity develops within a child as a result of the relationship it shares with its father and mother. Freud’s concepts of the Oedipus complex and Elektra complex go a long way towards the development of the theory of gender identity in children. Oedipus complex grows in boys when they grow up. They start desiring their mother sexually. At the same time, they suffer from castration anxiety in the fear that their father is more powerful and stands in way of his desire for his mother. This makes the boy internalize his father wants to be like him. This becomes his superego and the boy puts on the male gender identity. The Elektra complex grows in girls in a similar way when they grow up and the girl identifies herself with her mother (Sammons, n. d.).

Empirical Evidence
The Gender Schematic theory has been tested on forty-eight male and forty-eight female undergraduates. The results found show that sex-typed individuals show greater readiness in processing information including information about self, thereby supporting the hypothesis that sex-typing develops from gender-based schematic processing (Bem, 1981, p.361).

The psychoanalytic theory has not fared well on empirical evaluation. It has been found that boys of the age of four to six years hardly recognize the “differences between male and female genitalia” (Shaffer, 2009, pp. 264-265). Hence it is not likely that they would fear castration. Moreover, they identify strongly with their fathers in cases where the fathers are more caring than if they are threatening.

Conclusion
The theories of developmental psychology on gender identity put forth different arguments on the process that a child adopts on developing his or her own gender identity. The Gender Schema theory fares well in this aspect in explaining the cognitive approach towards child psychology. The psychoanalytic theory, although does not bear much empirical evidence in the modern world, holds enough value in extending elaborate explanations for the understanding of this subject. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Developmental Psychology (Compare and contrast two theoretical Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1465506-developmental-psychology-compare-and-contrast-two
(Developmental Psychology (Compare and Contrast Two Theoretical Essay)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1465506-developmental-psychology-compare-and-contrast-two.
“Developmental Psychology (Compare and Contrast Two Theoretical Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1465506-developmental-psychology-compare-and-contrast-two.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Developmental Psychology of Gender Identity in Children

Gender Socialization Across the Life Span

Gender socialization refers to the acquisition of gender identity and the roles expected of the different sexes (Stockard, 2006).... Gender socialization refers to the acquisition of gender identity and the roles expected of the different sexes (Stockard, 2006).... Psychoanalytic, social learning and cognitive developmental theories offer explanations of gender socialization and help us to understand how gender socialization endures throughout the life-span (Bern, 1983)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Bruce Reimer Case on the Nature vs Nurture Debate

Social Role Theory Parents' expectations on how their child behaves have much influence on a child's gender identity.... Running head: THEORIES of gender DEVELOPMENT Theories of gender development Insert Name Insert Insert 09 November 2011 Theories of gender Development: The Bruce Reimer Case on the Nature vs.... By the age of 3 years, most children identify themselves as boys or girls and can classify others as being of same sex or the other sex (Golombok & Fivush, 1994)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Biological Peculiarity between Males and Females

This paper will discuss the various theories of gender identity in relation to hormonal and behavioral influences.... Interaction between hormones and behavior, and how they affect the determination of gender identity Most individuals use social indicators to determine a person's sex rather than the physical appearance.... It is the combination of social indicators rather than a single off indicator that is necessary in determining the gender identity of an individual....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Characteristic Development in Primary Education

haracteristic development is a major field in children's education today.... children are the main assets of the country and when the community is sure of educating its children right, it can be sure of a secure future.... Whether it is related to child-centered play or developmentally appropriate practice, the approaches in character development will have to be re-evaluated to create the right combination for children of today's world....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Analysis of Statement that the Development of Childs Identity Is Best Understood as Development in Context

In the given essay, the author concedes with the statement that the development of a child's identity is best understood as 'development in context'.... The essay throws light on this concept and explains how the development of a child's identity is a co-linked phenomenon.... However, it is important to understand the concept of 'development in context' and its relation to identity formation first.... Berk (2006) claims that identity construction includes defining who one is, what one values and the directions one wishes to pursue in life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Gender Studie: Women's Point of View

The first point concerns the importance of social identity in the production of knowledge.... The paper "Gender Studie: Women's Point of View" presents that modern psychology pays much attention to the question of gender differences.... The relationships between anti-normative knowledge and sexual identity are more complex than just the belief that heterosexuals cannot overcome their 'straight' way of thinking.... The author is sure about the effectiveness of this method as for the understanding by people that sexual orientation as well as gender identification does not put a negative impact on the quality of study and education....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

The Role of Positive Emotions in Positive Psychology

n early childhood, culture expects younger children to start practicing some roles that are fit for that stage of life (Maria and Deise, 2012).... For example, an adult is allowed to marry, whereas children are expected to remain under their parents' care not marrying.... This report "The Role of Positive Emotions in Positive psychology" discusses human development that is affected by a variety of factors that are in most cases linked with one another rather than independent....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report

Development of Gender Roles

Coltrane and Adams (2008) opine that gender identity is, in essence, a concept that refers to the knowledge that a person has with regards to masculinity and femininity.... The paper "Development of gender Roles" highlights that social factors tend to determine the way in which an individual will perceive another sex type.... Parents, teachers, and other influential figures provide an avenue by which children get to understand the issues of gender....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us