StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Situations of Moral Dilemma - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the "Situations of Moral Dilemma" paper argues that a moral dilemma has to be weighed, and a judgment made based on the principle of nonviolence advocated by Gandhi. According to Gandhi, there is an amicable solution to every dilemma in life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Situations of Moral Dilemma
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Situations of Moral Dilemma"

Moral Dilemma In some life situations, individuals find themselves in moral dilemma. Moral dilemmas are challenging andtactical events in life. In the incident, an individual faces challenge on the choice of actions that places him or her in a moral dilemma on the best choice. Each action presents a test of the morality and each is justified based on a moral reason. In situations of moral dilemmas, an individual has to consider the ethical aspects that make the situation a dilemma. A moral dilemma has to be resolved considering the best ethical capability (Biasetti 17). That is, one has to find the best moral standards in order to solve the moral dilemma. The question demands an exclusive level of thinking to come up with the considerable moral solution. A moral dilemma has to be weighed, and a judgment made based on the principle of nonviolence advocated by Gandhi. According to Gandhi, there is an amicable solution to every dilemma in life. Gandhi advocated that moral dilemma should be solved by non-violent means. He understood violence to mean the philosophy of Ahimsa. Gandhi argued that the best man is who advocated Ahimsa. Ahimsa specifically means a nonviolent action. For Gandhi, he interpreted it meant love, love that prevents anybody from harming other people. Therefore, in a moral dilemma a decision has to be made considering the love for a person. A moral decision is the one that best takes the interests of a human being. In 1842, the captain of a lifeboat faced a dilemma when the lifeboat had to be occupied by thirty survivors but could only support seven (Biasetti 49). He had saved the thirty passengers from a boat that had capsized after hitting an iceberg. The captain decided to drown some of the weak survivors to save the stronger ones. According to Gandhi, the best decision was when he could have shown love for of them rather than drowning twenty-three survivors to save only seven. In a moral dilemma, the best decision made involves sacrifices. The person who has to make the best moral decision accepts Ahimsa. That is, despite the violence experienced by an individual he remains non-violent. In a moral dilemma, the decision made after sacrificing for others dependents on the circumstances initiating the moral dilemma (Biasetti 53). Gandhi holds that the most prudent decision is characteristic of courageous individuals. He argued that fear represents an aspect of violence to individuals. Accepting sufferings and remaining courageous attains a prudent solution for particular moral dilemma under any circumstances. The courage enhances the ability to think when faced with a problem presented by moral dilemma. Fear, however, increases the chances of making irrational decisions. Moral decisions should be based on the factual information. A decision made on mere fictional data is factually wrong. Therefore, the moral dilemma requires a high level of thinking that is highly based on factual data (Williams 87). Gandhi worked on non-violence Satyagraha: a principle that requires the establishment of truth in non-violent means. Hence, the moral dilemma would be best solved if the truth on a particular matter were, first, established. When the truth is established through the analysis of the factual data available, then the moral dilemma is best solved. It is challenging to acquire the information if the decision is required to be made urgently. However, efforts should be made to obtain any necessary information. In a moral dilemma, a kind of moral reason is always sacrificed. Thus, the choice made reflects the least moral sacrifice made. A moral dilemma is composed of two incompatible normative elements. One must be selected. The decision made will always represent an element where the decision made failed morally. Why should the decision fail to be made if moral failure must be reflected in the decision made? Samuel Johnson referred to the moral dilemma a situation that no existing theory can be applied (Williams, 96). The decision made is unique and is not similar to any decision made earlier. The moral dilemma does not exist in normal situations and when it comes it must be faced with effective rational interpretation. Some genuine dilemmas will exist in nature, but moral dilemmas are very outrageous and require a high level of thinking. Despite how critical it might be a critical dilemma must be faced. In the study of moral philosophy, Kant advocated on moral decisions made on what ought to be. That is, a consequential consideration should be made any time a moral decision is made. The Kant ideas limit us from the responsibility that we have of making decisions. The human must face the laws of nature through the application of the laws of reason (Williams 101). The moral dilemma is an element of nature that must be intelligently faced with elements of reason. Kant required the application of good intent when making the moral decisions. The moral dilemmas must come, and they must be faced with a high level of intelligence and solved with good will. Although, the moral dilemmas are not experienced daily when they come they challenged the subject’s level of thinking. People have diverse concepts about what is considered morally upright. Therefore, the decisions made by an individual will always contradict with one another in similar situations. For instance, a situation in which a man decided to kill his daughter so that he can make her escape from the acts of violation. Individuals may think that the violation may be compromised if the main aim is to save an individual from death. The attitudes towards the killing will also influence the decision made especially between believers and non-believers. That is; different moral considerations will be applied to different individuals when faced with similar circumstances of moral dilemma. The fact raises questions over arriving at the best decision despite the use of rationality (Richard, 43). In all the situations, the idea of love will be applied. Nevertheless, when the love and sufferings elements are applied simultaneously, the problem with different moral consideration will be solved. Moreover, the decisions in moral dilemma are required to be made with high level of intelligence. For this reason, the decision related to killing the daughter due to saving her from acts of violation with not be made out of irrationality. Nevertheless, it is argued that the element of nonviolence did not exclude individuals from taking different moral considerations. Why would the same decisions made under similar standard arrive at different solutions? He believed that the individuals taking himsa decisions should be allowed to move through that path. However, he thought that he had the responsibility to assist them make ahimsa decisions (Richard, 46). Arriving at different solutions will not be avoided despite any precaution being taken. Gandhi himself was faced with a similar situation. It was proposed to Gandhi that it was inevitable to kill those individuals who were oppressors of humankind. Their actions were compared to those of a homicidal lunatic. Gandhi argued that there was no man who was so evil that he could not be redeemed. Moreover, no man who was so perfect that he was justified to kill those noted to be evil. For this reason, arriving at different solutions to moral dilemma could not be avoided. The fact was that at that instance the Gandhi was faced with a situation of moral dilemma. He took a different position depending on what he believed was correct and morally right. The rights to make decisions are bestowed on a human being. When faced with a moral dilemma a decision has to be made. Human beings are moral agents. Therefore, obligations have been placed on the human being to make decisions on moral issues. The best way to take the approach is clearly understanding all elements that are manifested in a certain dilemma (Richard 49). It is important to note that a moral decision is very tricky to make and deserves a high level of thinking. The decision made on moral dilemma must also reflect sacrifice and love for humanity. In addition, the decisions must be made courageously so that to arrive at the best decision. Nevertheless, there is the difficulty of arriving at different moral solutions. Arriving at different moral solutions is caused by what different people consider morally upright. Nevertheless, the problem can be solved by applying different standards concurrently. First, every decision should be made with high level of rationality and intelligence. Second, an individual should be guided by the love of humanity. Third, sacrifice should be an element that guides individuals in solving the moral dilemma. Finally, every decision should be made with good intent. Works Cited Biasetti, Pierfrancesco. "Rights, Duties, and Moral Conflicts." Etica & Politica 17.2 (2014): 1044-1064. http://www2.units.it/etica/2014_2/BIASETTI.pdf Richards, Glyn. The philosophy of Gandhi: A study of his basic ideas. Routledge, 2005. Print. Williams, Bernard. Morality: An introduction to ethics. Cambridge University Press, 2012. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1872114-gandhi
(Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1872114-gandhi.
“Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1872114-gandhi.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Situations of Moral Dilemma

Professional Moral Compass

A doctor is placed in a critical dilemma in caring for continuing illness or certain deaths.... Nurses' loyalty belong to the physicians and members of the team committed to care of the patients and according to the reading, physicians are often left in a dilemma to fulfill their obligations in dying patients.... Professional moral Compass Date Professional moral Compass Introduction The Chapter 3 reading entitled “To Heal Sometimes, To Comfort Always of the President's Council on Bioethics discussed the role of medicine both within the doctors and patients perspectives....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethical Dilemma of Personality

In the similar way, the situation can also be called as a moral situation in which the teacher is bound by the moral principles of class and he is in moral dilemma.... James is a teacher of ninth grade, who are teenage students and understand the situations of the class very well.... Ethical dilemma [Author] [Institution] Introduction Professional ethics tend to exist in all the aspects in which social relationships are involved.... Ethical dilemma is known to be the complex situation in which one might get when he has a mental conflict between moral essentials in which it is known that the choice of one may result in disobeying the other....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ethical Dilemma on Case Manager

From the paper "Ethical dilemma on Case Manager " it is clear that the ability of a patient to pay, details about the insurance cover, and the expectations of the nurses or doctors play a critical role in the process of dealing with ethical dilemmas.... Nurse Managers are faced with the dilemma of balancing patients' care and supervisory roles.... The call for extra responsibility has proved to be a dilemma as the medical field continues to suffer from an acute shortage of medical personnel (Icheku, 2011)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethics and corrections

Persons involved in correctional facilities faces ethical dilemma's on a daily basis.... o the dilemma in corrections can be seen as decisions and actions that needs to be taken in order to facilitate due process of rehabilitation, and in certain circumstances doing good will result in bad consequences, in others implementing negative or bad will have positive results.... Even with this ethical system it is not always clear what action is the correct one, as when a person is facing a dilemma where an unmoral action will result in a positive outcome....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What Exactly Is a Moral Dilemma

The paper "What Exactly Is a moral dilemma" discusses that state laws prevent a pregnant woman from writing a 'living will' and attempting to withhold or withdraw treatment.... The main issue or moral dilemma would be whether the woman must opt to have chemotherapy or not.... Is it possible for the woman to be able to reason out, eventually, which horn of the moral dilemma would in fact be the best choice possible?... moral dilemmas can also arise when, for one, a competent adult patient refuses treatment on religious grounds, when the patient is incompetent, and his wishes are never expressed when the patient had expressed the wish to withhold treatment before he became incompetent, and the parent who decides to withhold treatment on behalf of her child....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

The Conception of Moral Dilemmas

The paper "The Conception of Moral Dilemmas" discusses that generally speaking, the complexity of a moral dilemma is determined by the consequences and past experiences.... A moral dilemma can be delineated as a rational situation in which an individual is faced with different options and where a decision is made at the expense of another.... This further defines a moral dilemma in ethical terms.... The fundamentals of a moral dilemma may include: a situation where an individual (agent) is obligated to do every one of the actions (two or more) deeds, a person is fully capable of doing either of the actions, but cannot do both of the actions (Spector, 17)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Situations

At times these professional standards and professional ethics conflict, and the teacher face a situation of ethical dilemma in which he does not understand the complexity of deciding under moral principles.... The paper "Ethical Dilemmas and moral Situations" states that professional ethics tend to exist in all the aspects in which social relationships are involved.... The situation I experienced deals with many of the problems associated with moral and ethical dilemmas, and unfortunately, they exist quite often in the day to day teaching practices....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Process of Moral Decision

The paper 'The Process of moral Decision' presents a moral decision that has always been a difficult thing to make.... That is why the mechanism of moral decision making is really interesting to analyze.... There is one more model of moral decision making.... he process of moral decision-making may be regarded as one of the central issues of moral psychology.... It aims to investigate factors that influence the process of moral decision making....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us