StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Borrowed from the Reagan-era war on drugs, the phrase "zero tolerance" is now being applied as a judicial model by universities and government agencies in investigation and prosecution of charges of harassment and discrimination. The principle of zero tolerance is that once an accusation is made of, say, sexual abuse, violence against women, or profanity in the schools, it should be followed by immediate arrest of the alleged perpetrator, even if the accusation was made anonymously…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Does Zero Tolerance Policing work
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'"

Download file to see previous pages

The administrators objected to having to enforce the principle of zero tolerance on the grounds that they would have to go in with a police escort, even on the basis of a sliver of a rumour about a picture you don't like. Defenders of the policy reply that it indicates a greater willingness to take such complaints seriously. This type of policy of reversing the burden of proof is a species of argumentum ad ignorantiam of the following form: if you can't prove that you are not guilty, then it is presumed that you are guilty.

Normally, the burden is on the accuser to provide evidence or corroboration of the charge. Admittedly, where an event took place privately between two people, with no physical evidence of harm, it is generally hard to prove such objective corroboration. The solution advocated by the zero tolerance principle is to shift the burden of disproof of the charge onto the side of the accused party. If he can't furnish such evidence, the conclusion we should draw by the ad ignorantiam argument is that he is guilty.

Is this a reasonable or fallacious use of the argument from ignorance This is a hotly disputed question at the moment. Defenders of zero tolerance argue that the application of the argument from ignorance, as a reasonable argument in this instance, is justified by argument from consequences: namely, those women are at present suffering from abuse to such a degree that anyone who opposes zero tolerance is causing the deaths of women. Opponents of the principle also base their opposition on the argument from consequences.

They argue that the policy of zero tolerance is producing many innocent victims of false charges of abuse, and having a disastrous effect on families. Opponents of the policy also argue that the advocates of zero tolerance are focusing only on the consequences as they affect one group, and ignoring the impact on anyone who is not a member of this group. They see this as a form of self-interested bargaining or advocacy dialogue taking the place of a more rational and objective type of deliberation or critical discussion that takes all points of view into account.

At any rate, on this controversial issue, the central question directly relates to the argumentum ad ignorantiam as a type of argument. Is it reasonable or fallacious in this case And what are the grounds for justifying one opinion or the other Significantly, zero tolerance policing, with its more assertive and control oriented message, seems to have struck a chord in recent years. An increasing number of public-initiated police contacts are crime-related, especially in inner-city areas and in a time of stretched resources many have argued that police duties should be more closely restricted to crime-work.

This was the dominant message behind the setting up inquiry into core policing tasks, which, despite denials, was envisaged as clearing the way towards the privatization of alleged 'peripheral' police-work. While the conclusions of the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work
(Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'Work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work.
“Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'Work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'

Zero Tolerance Policies for Schools

In the paper “zero tolerance Policies for Schools” the author emphasizes why zero tolerance in schools is an important legislative, judicial or public policy issue while elaborating on its potential direct effect on education.... hellip; The author states that zero tolerance policy eliminating students who involve themselves in deviant behaviors will prohibit others from becoming disruptive.... In most instances, such cases are rationalized as sacrifices that are necessary if zero tolerance has to be fairly applied and be effective in creating a deterrent effect....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Problem-Oriented Policing

There are two major policy perspectives that can be studying when broaching this subject; they include problem oriented policing and zero-tolerance policing.... One of the more popular areas where policies have been implemented has been in the issue of policing and the creation of rules that govern law and order (Ratcliffe, 2008).... Problem Oriented policing This policy perspective refers to a strategy that focuses on the problem that is being faced in a bid to come up with effective ways with which to deal with that specific problem (Taylor, 2007)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Are zero tolerance rules the best way to keep schools safe

Thus, the zero tolerance rules.... According to Ted Watchel, zero tolerance “have become commonplace in American schools in recent decades' (par.... Although many people agree to the zero tolerance rule policy in schools, this does not ensure a totally safe learning environment.... zero tolerance policies are ineffective and have even been harmful to students and school environments (Watchel, par.... Watchel further stated that, “The American Psychological Association zero tolerance Task Force issued a report in 2008 concluding that severe punishment at schools neither reduces violence nor promotes learning....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Bullying and Zero Tolerance Policies

In this study we are trying to find out the extent of the problem and to see if the policy of zero tolerance will be effective in reducing bullying incidents that are taking place.... The data has been gathered from a multi-cultural society to ensure that the results are not biased and represent the whole society not just a sub-sector. From this table we can see that parents are not particularly satisfied with the solutions they have experienced and they would like to try out the zero tolerance policy....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Zero Tolerance Policing in the UK

This term "zero tolerance policing" is simply referred to as Positive Policing by the UK Government.... hellip; To achieve this, the department of zero tolerance policing should be made independent so that it may be free from any external interference by "the invisible hand".... Such an idea is what shook the United Kingdom to the realization that led them to embrace modern methods of fighting against the vise [zero tolerance policing].... his new direction that zero tolerance policing has taken must therefore factor in these two concerns and work towards improving the relationship....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

PA Mod 2 New Homeland Security Challenges

Although both community policing and zero tolerance policing are all designed to help fight against crime and criminal activities, zero tolerance policing often works against the goals of community policing particularly with regard to the efforts of logical crime prevention.... For example, most citizens and members of the communities generally view the street sweeps aimed at enhancing zero tolerance policing to be biased, brutal and militaristic....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Violence and Teachers Perception of the Zero Tolerance Policy

Currently, "zero tolerance" is the official disciplinary policy used in schools to counter cases of violence.... This is evident not only from statistics showing prevalence of violence in American schools, but also from extensive portrayal of the same in diverse… Cases of knife stabbing, mass shootouts, as well as, physical bullying continue to be significantly challenging issues, especially in public schools....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Zero Tolerance Policing and its Role in the Modern UK Policing Strategy

This research paper will look at how the government of the UK has faired so far with its strategy of zero tolerance policing since its inception, and what the government has so far achieved.... To achieve this, the department of zero tolerance policing should be made independent so that it may be free from any external interference by “the invisible hand”.... Such an idea is what shook the United Kingdom to the realization that it led them to embrace modern methods of fighting against the vise [zero tolerance policing]....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us