StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Facts. Mr. A has been detained by the police as a potential material witness to a murder. During the course of the investigation, it is discovered that Mr. A has an outstanding warrant on a parole violation and he is arrested. As part of his processing into the temporary jail facility, his clothes are taken, inventoried, and stored…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust"

Download file to see previous pages

The basis for the murder charge in this case hinges on the use of the blood evidence found on Mr. A's shoes as an indicator that he was at the scene of the crime proximate to the death of the victim. The collection of that evidence eight days after his arrest on unrelated charges constitutes a search and as such, is subject to a two-prong test of the standard rules of evidentiary procedure as well as the doctrine of "reasonableness."1 This particular search fails on both prongs. First, the police waited too long to take Mr.

A's clothing to the forensics lab. Had the officers decided to have the clothing tested when they discovered that Mr. A had an outstanding warrant, they might have been able to make a case for a search incident to arrest and tied the two incidents together. That itself would probably be questionable, however, due to the fact that the arrest was for a parole violation and not related to the murder. Certainly, waiting eight days to send the clothing over to the lab constituted a search and seizure of Mr.

A's property; one that required more than simply obtaining the clothing from the evidence locker and sending it to forensics for analysis. For this search to be conducted at such a late date and still remain within the rules of evidence collection, the police officers needed to provide a judge with probably cause so that a search warrant could be issued. The police are not allowed to simply go on a fishing expedition, even though they might suspect that Mr. A could be more than a material witness.

Accordingly, the subjection of the clothing to the lab violates the rules of evidence collection under standard criminal procedure and fails the first prong.Similarly, the search of Mr. A's clothing violates the doctrine of reasonable expectation. As Saltzburg (2003) notes, "[t]he Supreme Court has long used a standard of reasonability to determine what citizens should be able to expect from encounters with law enforcement officials as well as how officers should act" (p. 145). There is no doubt that Mr.

A had the right to expect reasonable behavior from the police regarding the murder investigation. First, this reasonable behavior on the part of officials might have included a search of his property within the scope of the charges for which he was arrested. Had the officers been gathering evidence of his parole violation, they would have been reasonably acting in accordance with the rules. Second, Mr. A could reasonably expect that if he was considered a suspect in an investigation unrelated to the parole violation charges, he would be advised of that inquiry so that he could retain counsel or inform his attorney and protect his rights.

This did not happen prior to the search. Finally, after being advised of the new charges pending against him, Mr. A would have the right to expect the police to act in a timely manner and perform their search incident to his arrest for that crime. None of these things occurred, and the delay in searching his property for an unrelated crime-combined with the charges being filed after the unlawful search and seizure of his clothing-was unreasonable and a violation of his rights. Thus, the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500872-the-case-of-mr-a-bad-bust
(The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500872-the-case-of-mr-a-bad-bust.
“The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500872-the-case-of-mr-a-bad-bust.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Case of Mr. A: Bad Bust

Medical Emergency Doctor Profession

Allan Hughes was accompanied by his wife who sat at the side of mr.... All fields medical requires an emergence room doctor; he can be a physician, a surgeon or even gynecologist. … mr.... The old man by the name mr.... After mr.... mr.... As a child mr.... His first case was of a child who had developed a tumor in his heart the tumor extended so much and the boy required an emergency operation to correct the situation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Criminal Theft Act 1968

Similarly in the case of Jane, under s3 Theft Act 1968, she innocently or intentionally is keeping the money with her, however in the case of candles which Jane borrows refers to the s2 (1) (b) where Jane is not considered under Theft Act s 3 as she has borrowed them and is in intention to gave them back.... 43) But then she uses the candles which comes under the case of an offence under the Theft Act 1968, where the property in question is recovered, any damage to the property occurring while it was out of the owner's possession shall be treated for the purposes of subsection (1) as having resulted from the offence, however and by whomsoever the damage was caused....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Tort Law: Analysis of Watkins v Secretary of State for the Home Department and Others Case

Watkin made frequent complaints that he was being treated by prison officers in a manner that conflicted with the requirement of r37A (or r39, as the case might be).... Judge Ibbotson sitting in the Leeds County Court on 15 July 2003 found that three prison officers had acted in bad faith when dealing with his legally-privileged correspondence.... The author examines Watkins v Secretary of State for the Home Department and Others case about mr....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

The Land and Property Act

The following paper under the title 'The Land and Property Act' presents the most important issue that arises in the case of the property Dave and Maggie want to purchase is the restrictive covenant that prevents the use of the land for the sale of alcohol.... It is not immediately clear who can press for enforcement of this restrictive covenant, which was the same issue raised in the case of Crest.... However, working in their favor is the recent case of Sugarman and Porter and Others5 where an existing restrictive covenant on a property was deemed to be valid only up to the period the land remained unsold....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Berkoff v Burchill - Defining the Scope of Defamatory Statement

 Material Facts of the CaseIn the 30 January 1994 issue of the Sunday Times, Miss Burchill, in her review of the film “The Age of Innocence” wrote that the “film directors, from Hitchcock to Berkoff, are notoriously hideous-looking people…” Nine months after Miss Burchill made that comment on the looks of mr.... the case Berkoff v Burchill was original was heard by the High Court presided over by Sir Maurice Drake.... On the evaluation of the facts of the case and the arguments presented by the parties, Sir Maurice Drake “dismissed the defendant's application, but he gave the defendants leave to appeal....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Intended Purpose of the Criminal Evidence Act 1898

nbsp;… The Commission felt that evidence of bad character should be limited to similar facts to the matter at hand and that a test based on the probative value whilst limiting the prejudicial value should be applied.... The original wording of s1(f) (iii) stated that an accused person who has given evidence against another person charged with the same offence may be cross-examined about his previous convictions and his bad character.... In recent times attempts have been made to clarify the law in respect of evidence of bad character through the introduction of the Criminal Justice Act 2003....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Ethical Problems to Be Solved with a Code of Conduct of the American Psychological Association

To give a brief definition of the case, it is necessary to mention that after a concussion, the patient found himself in a condition in which he could no longer rely on his cognition alone, but needed coordination and guidance.... hellip; Within this scenario, it remains not reasonably vivid whether mr.... The counselor also attracted other people to assist mr.... The release was quite a disputable and problematic document because it was not likely that mr....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Admissibility of Evidence in the Widdowson Case

hellip; the case deals with the circumstances surrounding the attempted murder of the Plaintiff Mr.... nbsp; The testimonies by the two suspects in the case are a bit conflicting.... This paper “Admissibility of Evidence in the Widdowson Case” seeks to establish the admissibility of evidence provided in a case involving the plaintiff, mr.... The two acquaintances, mr.... Andrew, and mr.... The two accused persons are said to have paid mr....
21 Pages (5250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us