StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Napoleon in Egypt - Scholarship Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Napoleon in Egypt" describes that The importance of Napoleon's expedition to Egypt includes the military and strategic aspects. In strictly strategic terms it was an unmitigated failure. It did not secure Egypt for the French nor did it see a French-controlled Suez canal built…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Napoleon in Egypt
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Napoleon in Egypt"

Napoleon in Egypt Introduction Following the capture of Tyre and the successful conclusion of the siege of Gaza in October 332 BC Alexander the Greathad isolated Egypt from the remainder of the Persian empire. Consequently, his entry was accomplished without any resistance. Alexander immediately set about the practical duties of conqueror--grain purchasing arrangements were concluded and the construction of the new port of Alexandria was started.1 However, according to biographer, Peter Green, Alexander was not concerned only with matters temporal. "It is no exaggeration to say that the months Alexander spent in Egypt, from late October 332 till April 331, marked a psychological turning-point in his life." By right of conquest Alexander "became simultaneously god and king, incarnation and son of Ra and Osiris; he was Horus the Golden One, the mighty prince, beloved of Amen, King of Upper and Lower Egypt."2 Previously, in Macedonia, rumours of Alexander being the son of a God had circulated. His mother claimed his father was Zeus-Ammon and it was said that he had a ring as a token of this paternity. However, it was in Egypt for the first time "he learnt that he was in truth a god, and the son of a god. Greek tradition distinguished sharply between the two; Egypt did not."3 He was not merely the son of a God but a God. Over two millennia later another rising military and imperial star, Napoleon Bonaparte invaded Egypt. Like Alexander before him, Napoleon, for a host of diverse reasons, both personal and political, opportunistic and strategic, turned his eyes to the Nile delta. The campaign is regarded as one of his first defeats. However, while it may have been a failure militarily, and was followed by Bonaparte becoming First Consul, then Emperor, and it had profound consequences on European history beyond the military and strategic. Napoleon in Egypt The months Napoleon spent in Egypt cannot be described as a psychological turning-point in his life, as they were for Alexander. However, the fact of the matter is that, Napoleon departed for Egypt as a leading military leader and returned a candidate for Emperor. Militarily, the campaign was a defeat. The Army of Italy was shipped to Egypt and campaigned along the Nile. It won some battles and it lost some battles. Ultimately, Nelson destroyed the French fleet in Aboukir Bay and left the army stranded in Egypt. At this point Napoleon returned to France where he became First Consul. Critics argue he abandoned his army in Egypt. His advocates claim he returned to the seat of government to rescue the Revolution. His motives for the invasion are also manifold and unclear. Strategically, the objective was to drive the British from their last remaining bastion in the eastern Mediterranean. According to Stuart Harten research into the construction of a Suez canal was the intention of the military and the scientific aspects of the expedition.4 Personally, it looked like easy prey and Napoleon needed another victory to burnish his image because the lustre of Italy was fading. Also, like Alexander, Napoleon had scientific and spiritual interest in Egypt. Prior to invading Egypt, Napoleon “sought the advice of chemist Claude-Louis Berthollet (1748–1822) and invited around 150 scientists, artists, engineers and surgeons – known as the savants – to accompany him to Egypt.” Humphries describes the enormity of the undertaking: “The formation of a scientific institute in a foreign land [Institut d’Égypte], the collection and detailing of every aspect of current and ancient life there and the (at least attempted) removal of a large number of artefacts – including the Rosetta stone – for study back in France.” He also cannot resist editorializing, “it is hard to think of a similar military campaign that has been so scientifically bold.... A feat of unparalleled brilliance.”5 Among its achievements was not the destruction of the nose on the sphinx. Many believe the story that Napoleon had cannon destroy the face of the Sphinx when it refused to answer his question. Geromes Napoleon and the Sphinx may have fed into that story, but it is exactly that, only a story. (Sketches of the Sphinx pre-dating the French invasion, show it without a nose.) In fact, that story could not be further from the truth. According to Stuart Harten the French carried off so many artefacts, and inventoried and sketched so many more that they could not carry off that they “radically recentered the geographical map of European culture, shifting the axis from St. Peters in Rome to the Louvre in Paris.”6 The work of the savants made Paris the cultural centre of the world. It also introduced the world to the word Orientalist – one who paints or writes about ancient cultures of the eastern Mediterranean. “The Rosetta Stone paved the way to the decipherment of hieroglyphics and the birth of modern Egyptology, and the Description [Description de lÉgypte, (1809-1829)] advanced the documentation of pharaonic art, architecture, and topography,” according to Donald Malcolm Reid.7 It made Paris the centre of the cultural world geographically and the ancient Orient the centre of the cultural world spiritually. These revolutionary cultural shifts were direct results of Napoleons expedition to Egypt. Napoleon and the Sphinx. by Jean Gerome, 1862 They even out weighted the ultimate disposition of the Rosetta Stone itself. The Rosetta Stone had ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs, other Egyptian script and Ancient Greek: Three languages, one text. It meant that readers of Ancient Greek could begin translating it into ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs and vis versa. The secrets of the language of the pyramid builders was cracked by the Rosetta stone. The British seized the Rosetta stone when they defeated the French in Egypt and took it to London but it was still France that became the cultural centre of Europe after Napoleons expedition to Egypt. Edward P. F. Rose focuses on the earth scientists that accompanied Napoleon. He argues that they were the first geologists to work under the auspices of any army. However, he does not mention their work on a potential canal, suggests they were of little use militarily, but “seized the opportunity to conduct exploration geology in a relatively little-known landscape with an easily recognizable enthusiasm.”8 They conducted geological research for its own sake, not merely as an adjunct to their engineering and more practical military responsibilities. Along with Orientalists and earth scientists Napoleon brought natural historians such as Etienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1772–1844). Paul Humphries describes his Indiana Jones-like escapades: Geoffroy “spent almost four gruelling years living in conditions ranging from luxurious to squalid, traipsing over scorching deserts wracked with thirst, dodging the swords and canons of the Mamelukes – the dreaded warrior tribe then ruling Egypt – attempting to avoid the ravages of the plague and being besieged by the Turks and British.”9 Despite these burdens they sketched wildlife, collected specimens and documented astronomical and other data. Like the geologists they were first and foremost scientists, not military men with additional scientific responsibilities. According to Ann Godlewska the savants were not military men but they were as much imperial conquerors, remodelers and expropriators as the imperial military machine. “The Description creates the Egypt that could be claimed and taken home and mathematically and rigorously interpreted in the silence of French libraries laboratories and museums without the difficult complications associated with colonialism, subject peoples and the bizarreries of other cultures.”10 Paris became the cultural epicentre of the world because Napoleons savants packaged Egypt like take away food and shipped it home. Anything they left behind the British shipped to London. The imperial struggle between Napoleons France and Great Britain was a war for culture and a war for hearts and minds, as well as a war for military and strategic domination. Conclusions The importance of Napoleons expedition to Egypt includes the military and strategic aspects but also extends well beyond them. In strictly strategic terms it was an unmitigated failure. It did not secure Egypt for the French nor did it see a French controlled Suez canal built. The French fleet was defeated and the army was isolated. That said, it is impossible to deny that it had positive effects on the career of its military leader, Napoleon Bonaparte. It directly led to Napoleons selection as First Consul and set him on the path to Emperor. However, its impact extended beyond, strategy and diplomacy. It was also a cultural and scientific expedition. This in and of itself was a revolutionary change: An army marching with a compliment of scholars alongside. The cultural warriors were to catalogue the extend of the new dominions and also collect the must meaningful artefacts and ship them to the heart of the revolution and the empire, Paris. In this sense it was a cultural war to colonize ancient Egypt but also a stroke against Great Britain in the imperial war for cultural dominance. In this sense it makes one aware of the ultimate power of the revolution: No longer did state fight state but nation fought nation and culture had become part of the battleground. The Research Process I started my search by logging into the library website. This convenient feature allowed me to do much of my research online although hard copy library research also had its rewards. The first resource I located using the library catalogue was in the librarys E-book collection. I searched the research terms Napoleon and Egypt and searched E-Resources with a single result. It was Donald Malcolm Reids Whose pharaohs?: archaeology, museums, and Egyptian national identity from Napoleon to World War I ACLS Humanities E-Book. This book immediately introduced the cultural and scientific purposes and impacts of the expedition. It also quickly proved the importance of searching for resources online and using online resources. On the downside this resource only produced a single result. To obtain more results I could have taken two approaches. I could have used only a single search term – Napoleon – or I could have searched the entire library catalogue – including hard copy books – to increase the number of results. Therefore, I next stared using the search tools for academic periodicals online. On “EBSCO” I used search terms Napoleon, Egypt and it returned five results. The first was Edward P. F. Roses article, “Napoleon Bonapartes Egyptian campaign of 1798: the first military operation assisted by geologists?” This article broadened my understanding of the scope of the scientific disciplines that the savants were composed of. “EBSCO” is a very useful database. It references academic, full-text periodicals and with my two search terms provided quick access to five relevant articles. Then using “JLOSTAR” I found “Map, Text and Image. The Mentality of Enlightened Conquerors: A New Look at the Description de lEgypte” by Anne Godlewska. It was the seventh article in a search that returned 8462 results. “JLOSTAR” is a valuable database for research. It references academic periodicals and the search can be limited to full-text articles. If the 8462 results had not yielded relevant results quickly I would have had to add a third search term to narrow the search down. Searching various more general databases I located the chapter by Stuart Harten, “Rediscovering Ancient Egypt: Bonapartes Expedition and the Colonial Ideology of the French Revolution” in Napoleon in Egypt, edited by Irene A. Bierman on Google Books. The search Napoleon and Egypt on Google Books produced 373,000 hits. The Bierman book was the first result, and the chapter “Rediscovering Ancient Egypt: Bonapartes Expedition and the Colonial Ideology of the French Revolution” was included in its entirety in the free preview. This article linked with Godlewskas article. Her article detailed the theory of the ideology and this article outlined the application of the ideology. The problem with Google Books is that it does not contain the full-text of all the books it links to and it is more of a tool for building a bibliography that can then be found in the library catalogue rather than a research tool. That said in this particular instance the section of the book that was reproduced in Google Books happened to be the precise source I needed. One resource I found by a stroke of good luck. When I searched the library catalogue under emperor and egypt manys books about Alexander the Great turned up. I went and scanned through one of these looking for Napoleon in the index. That is how I found the Peter Green book that provided the anecdote for the introduction. It also reveals that even with outstanding online resources available at University of Exeter there is still a place for books and old style shelf-walking in research today. The most important thing I learned about research during the course of this assignment was the importance of using a variety of search tools and techniques. No single database, catalogue or search tool contained all the resources available. Research was like finding the pieces of the puzzle before beginning to assemble the puzzle, and the pieces were hidden all over the place not in just one research resource. The assignment demonstrated that I need a kit of research tools and that no one research tool alone is enough. References Godlewska, Anne. “Map, Text and Image. The Mentality of Enlightened Conquerors: A New Look at the Description de lEgypte” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers New Series, Volume 20, Number 1 (1995), pp. 5-28. . Green, Peter Alexander of Macedon, 356-323 B C University of California Press Berkeley, CA: 1991. Harten, Stuart “Rediscovering Ancient Egypt: Bonapartes Expedition and the Colonial Ideology of the French Revolution” in Napoleon in Egypt. Irene A. Bierman, editor, Garnett Publishing, Reading, 2003, pp. 33-46. Humphries, P. “Blind ambition: Geoffroy St-Hilaires theory of everything” Endeavour Volume 31, Issue 4 (December 2007), pp. 134-139. Reid, Donald Malcolm. Whose pharaohs?: archaeology, museums, and Egyptian national identity from Napoleon to World War I ACLS Humanities E-Book. . Rose, Edward P. F. “Napoleon Bonapartes Egyptian campaign of 1798: the first military operation assisted by geologists?” Geology Today, Volume 20, Number 1 (January 01, 2004), pp. 24-29, . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Napoleon in Egypt Scholarship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
Napoleon in Egypt Scholarship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1574875-napoleon-in-egypt-and-his-effect-on-education-newspaper-edition-military
(Napoleon in Egypt Scholarship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Napoleon in Egypt Scholarship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1574875-napoleon-in-egypt-and-his-effect-on-education-newspaper-edition-military.
“Napoleon in Egypt Scholarship Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/history/1574875-napoleon-in-egypt-and-his-effect-on-education-newspaper-edition-military.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Napoleon in Egypt

Napoleon in Egypt vs Manet Gypsy with Cigarette

Gerome (Napoleon in Egypt) v/s Manet (Gypsy with Cigarette) A comparative Study between the two paintings Academia-research.... om Meghana Gerome (Napoleon in Egypt) v/s Manet (Gypsy with Cigarette) Introduction to French Artistic Movement: The artistic movement in France has a prolonged history.... The masterpieces of these two painters we have taken are “Napoleon in Egypt,” and “Gypsy with Cigarette.... Keywords: artistic movement, France, romanticism, impressionism, Napoleon in Egypt, Gypsy with Cigarette Romanticism and impressionism: The period of Romanticism has the element of heroism....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Napoleon's Quest to Conquer Egypt

The goal of The present essay is to critically discuss the French invasion in egypt under the reign of Napoleon in the late 18th century.... Eventually, Ibrahim Bey and Murad Bey succeeded in declaring their authority and shared power in egypt.... An author of the essay aims to investigate why Napoleon has chosen to embark on the ambitious quest to conquer egypt.... hellip; One of the highlights of the world's history is the invasion of French by Napoleon Bonaparte's lead to egypt....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Naplion invasion of egypt and its impact on mehmed Ali

?Napoleon in Egypt: Al Jabartis Chronicle of the French Occupation, 1798.... This is because he aspired to capture Malta that would act as a Napoleon Invasion of Egypt and its Impact on Mehmed Ali On the year 1798, Napoleon Bonaparte led a French invasion in egypt that began with the capture of Alexandria.... This led to the isolation of French forces in egypt.... Furthermore,… Moreover, Napoleon believed that the capture of egypt would aid in the defeat of Britain....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Political Atmosphere in Middle East

This revived the re-examination of the traditional Islamic community in terms of its political, economical, educational, and the… As a result, major developments occurred in Modern Arabic Literature.... Notably was the growth of indigenous Journalism, the rise of new reading public, and the impact brought by the new-simpler Arabic prose style in writing....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Napoleon's Rule

  This paper seeks to look into napoleon who was an influential, prominent military and political icon that rose to power during the later times of the French Revolution.... he French Revolution and napoleon are of major importance to history because they brought about the modern warfare as it came to be referred to in the nineteenth and twentieth century.... France and all the satellite states it controlled had their resources availed to King napoleon for use in waging war and this saw the groundwork for war being set in the nineteenth century for a full-on war in the twentieth century....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Napoleon's Rise and Fall

He became the king of the world, concurring even the mighty egypt.... napoleon has played a very important role in the world history.... The paper "napoleon's Rise and Fall" analyzes his life way.... The writer characterizes napoleon's battle campaigns in Europe and his contributions to history such as liberalism, equal human rights for all and religious tolerance.... napoleon Bonaparte had a good education at an early age and later joined the army at an early age....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The Coronation of Emperor Napoleon I

Having been victorious in his campaigns in Italy and egypt, Napolean won military prestige and became the first Consul following the Brumaire Coup D'etat.... Although the artwork shows Empress Josephine being coronated by napoleon, it was napoleon who had first coronated himself on December 2, 1804 at Notre-Dame Cathedral.... napoleon had been consecrated by a Pope just as his predecessors Charlemagne a thousand years before....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

History Acceptance of Muslims in the World

The paper 'History Acceptance of Muslims in the World' suggests that Since 1798, beginning with the arrival of Napoleon in Egypt, the Middle East has been occupied by, ruled by, warred with, and made peace with European nations.... Muslims have bent to the occupations and influences of Western forces....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us