StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Disney and Studio Ghibli - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Disney and Studio Ghibli ' tells that Disney and Studio Ghibli both make children’s films. Despite the success amongst both adults and children of so-called children’s literature, especially in recent years, there is still a widely held stereotype that anything made for children is, indeed has to be, simplistic…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Disney and Studio Ghibli
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Disney and Studio Ghibli"

Because the intended audience of most animated films is children, they do not portray anything more than a narrow and overly-simplified world view. Discuss Disney and studio Ghibili both make children’s films. In spite of the success amongst both adults and children of so-called children’s literature, especially in recent years, there is still a widely held stereotype that anything made for children is, indeed has to be, simplistic. The films of Disney and studio Ghibili are no exception, with animated stories often held to be a particularly extreme example of over-simplification for simple minds. However, in both cases there is, in fact, an extremely potent under-lying messages designed to cater to a much more adult audience. For Disney, this is about convincing adults that Disney represents a reassuring consumerist model in keeping with American society and culture. By successfully convincing parents of this message, Disney ensures that parents will allow their children to become consumers of their products. By contrast, studio Ghibili’s message is designed for parents and children to understand on different levels. It is about believing in children’s ability to understand complex messages and instilling in them an understanding of issues related to globalization, such as the environment. It is clear therefore that both companies portray much more than a narrow and overly-simplified world view. This essay will explore how each production studio communicates its very different and very complex adult messages. The apparently simplistic way in which Disney construct their animated films is, in reality, very carefully planned and designed in order to promote the societal system which keeps Disney going – capitalism. Film studios such as Disney do not exist for humble artistic endeavor, but rather to manufacture products which can be sold to consumers for profit. The repetitive and familiar format of Disney films provides a reassurance of what consumers can expect and so encourages parents to trust in them and allow their children to consume them too. However, the Disney message does not stop there. Disney stores successfully sell to young consumers, encouraged by their parents to consume the Disney message. Further, Disney enters into the family holiday, encouraging parents to take their children to their theme parks. In short, Disney permeates the free-time of family life, encouraging the existing system of consumption to continue. Pinsky describes Disney theme parks as a short of shrine where adults re-live their childhoods through their children in a fantasy land. This concept of crossing generations makes Disney even more appealing to parents. Even within the films themselves, this message of capitalism and consumerism is promoted. As Keller (25) comments on Ariel and the contract she makes with the sea-witch in The Little Mermaid, ‘the contract symbolizes capitalist business rules to get something for nothing – since consumer purchase unnecessary and often unwanted goods with their money’. Ariel must make a capitalist contract to move to a better place. In this way, Disney films constantly repeat the capitalist message to their consumers. Studio Ghibili films also comment on society. However, their aim is not to promote the status quo, but rather to criticize and undermine it. Indeed, the films can be seen to take on quite serious environmental issues which they pass on to children in a far from over-simplified way. The characters within the films often act as symbolic references to issues such as pollution. The Stink God in Spirited Away is in fact revealed to be a water spirit, but he has become horribly contaminated. As Napier remarks, the spirit is liberated from the pollution of modern life in a move which condemns pollution. This is a powerful message to children about the ugly realities of consumer society. This criticism of society even becomes a concern at the loss of Japanese cultural identity itself. As Napier (287) comments on the film Spirited Away, it is ‘a reaction to globalization in which cultural products are used to reinforce notions of local culture as a form of resistance to perceived outside threats’. Chihiro, the young protagonist in the film, is regarded as a message to other Japanese children on how to resist modernity and respect nature. The two studios are, therefore, at odds. One defends modernity while the other recoils from it. However, both present a strong and serious message which is far from simplistic. In keeping with maintaining the social order, good and bad is very clear cut in Disney’s films. No where is this more evident than in the depiction of female characters. Women are given very clear social paths whereby good is represented by youth and beauty, with bad being represented by ugliness and old age. Women are also subject to the powerful will of men and so a highly conservative and traditional view of gender roles is promoted to children by Disney. Disney has been so criticized about its stereotypical women that it has recently tried to move away from the white-skinned, blond-haired, blue-eyed stereotype by focusing on characters such as Jasmine in Aladdin and Pocahontas. However as Hoff Kraemer’s article clearly states, the women continue to follow their stronger male characters and ultimately revert to type. In the end, they have to submit to marriage and passing any power they may have had to the male characters. Rather than being a simplistic message to pass on to children, this is in fact extremely serious, complex and deep psychological conditioning. It is teaching children about gender roles before they are even old enough to recognize gender differences. Indeed, it sets out to create a generation of little girls who will grow up to be just like their mothers. This way the patriarchal, capitalist society will move quietly forward. In stark contrast, Miyazaki and the Ghibili studios set out to disrupt the standard feminine stereotype. Indeed the director himself comments in Midnight Eye that he deliberately decided to have female protagonists since women are so resourceful and so strong. He was fascinated by female psychology and also believed that women may be the answer to the problems created by the very same patriarchal society which Disney continue to defend. Indeed Hoff Kraemer’s article is based round the idea that Miyazaki provides a much better role model than Disney for young women in the United States. This is because they are independent and critical thinkers who do not have to give way to men. Unlike Disney’s perfect, two-dimensional princesses, the girls of studio Ghibili ask questions, challenge assumptions and don’t give in to external pressure to change. A good example of this is the character San, who is not only leader of her people, but also questions what sort of authority she should have and how she should best serve her people as leader. These complex questions are a world away from the un-thinking women in Disney films and indeed as the film progresses, an evolution of the leadership skills of San is followed. Where Disney attempts to restrain and repress its females characters, studio Ghibili liberates them, encouraging them to take on traditionally male roles and, further, succeed at them. The use which the studios make of fantasy will finally be considered. In the Disney land of fairytales, children are led to believe in and respect the magical world on Kings, Queens and wicked witches. Disney is keen to draw on what is regarded as a fairytale heritage in order to make their films seem safe for children to consume. However, this fairytale world is just another way for Disney to promote its message of conformity. Fairytales were originally peasant tales based in nature and only began to contain aristocratic characters once they were taken up by the aristocracy to teach moral lessons to their children. The Disney characters are therefore far from innocent, but rather promote a belief in and respect for the existing ruling class. Disney plants in the minds of children that they should aspire to be rich and respect those who already are. Every little girl may want to be a princess after watching a Disney film, but this is actually a powerful message to be sending to parents and children about capitalist society and the pursuit of wealth. Studio Ghibili, on the other hand, puts fantasy to quite different use. Indeed, studio Ghibili uses fantasy to lock into ancients Japanese cultures and traditions based on historical beliefs in magic and the supernatural. This gives their films depth and therefore heighten the sense of reality and responsibility for the characters involved. It is clear, therefore, that Disney and studio Ghibili do far more than send out over-simplistic messages to children. In fact, their messages are quite in depth, complicated and often very subtle in the belief system they wish to pass on to children. However, this is where the similarities end. The messages themselves are clearly very different, with Disney encouraging their audience to respect, reflect and continue to follow the established order and studio Ghibili encouraging children to question the value systems of modern life. They are, therefore, two quite different messages promoted through very similar channels of communication. Works Cited Pinsky, Mark ‘Mickey Mouse and Faith?’ Keller, Sabine ‘The Disney characters are…”the very embodiment of consumer fetishism”. A critical reading’ Napier, Susan ‘Matter out of place: carnival, containment and cultural recovery in Miyazaki’s Spirited Away.’ Hoff Kraemer, Christine ‘Disney, Miyazaki and Feminism: Why Western girls need Japanese animation’ Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Disney and Studio Ghibli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 1, n.d.)
Disney and Studio Ghibli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1725388-compare-and-contrast-essay
(Disney and Studio Ghibli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1)
Disney and Studio Ghibli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1725388-compare-and-contrast-essay.
“Disney and Studio Ghibli Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1725388-compare-and-contrast-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Disney and Studio Ghibli

Persaude people to travel to Walt Disney World

Among its main attractions are the amazing Magic Kingdom, the Epcot building, Disneys Hollywood Studios and Disneys animal Kingdom, each allowing the visitors to get a real live view of either the creation and animation of cartoons, the history of the earth as it was formed and… nhabited life form, an inside look to the film industry to see how stunts are performed and enacted via various technological tools and machines, and a riveting display of the environment of different animals in the animal kingdom (Walt disney World, n....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

What Happened to Euro-Disney

In the following paper “What Happened to Euro-disney?... rdquo; the author focuses on the company giant of disney, which made serious mistakes in its strategic planning because of a certain degree of arrogance, as some of its executives had admitted belatedly.... This is exactly what happened to Euro-disney as the company had relied on its true and proven formula.... Senior disney executives could hardly be faulted for believing that the disney brand is a surefire success since it is a great global brand but their fault was in their execution plans....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Challenges of Disney Corporation

A second… disney generated $4.... Despite all Walt disney is one of the most successful companies in the entertainment industry.... disney generated $4.... A third weakness of disney is that it paid cero dividends during fiscal year 2011.... disney Corporation has many opportunities that it can take advantage of in order to increase its market share.... A second opportunity for the company is to use its copyright characters such as Mickey Mouse to produced new video games sponsored by disney....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Risk and Benefits of Expanding the Disney Brand in New Ways

One of the main benefits of growing with disney is the fact that it has a strong brand equity to it.... The experience disney offers in unparalleled compared to any other adventure.... The brand equity that disney provides is exclusive and Question - What are the risk and benefits of expanding the disney brand in new ways.... disney is one of the most prominent entertainment and leisure brand that is growing for many ages....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Disney case study

The region boasts a host of cultures, who are widely knowledgeable of Walt disney and its characters.... First, disney Hong Kong has put a lot of emphasis on Chinese culture and has incorporated it terms of building designs, marketing strategies and also in the food served.... Therefore, disney Shanghai will seek… Secondly, the target market in Chinese is now familiar with the disney brands, including its famous character Mickey Mouse....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Analysis of Disneys Powerful Marketing Machine Article by Ryan Tracy

The paper contains an evaluation of the article disney's Powerful Marketing Machine by Ryan Tracy which can sufficiently form a basis from which the various aspects of marketing channel can be weighed.... The article looks at the various marketing and business tools used by disney as a company.... disney has interests in a wide array of fields, and this makes it much easier for it to successfully market most of the products.... In light of this definition, an evaluation of the article disney's Powerful Marketing Machine by Ryan Tracy can sufficiently form a basis from which the various aspects of marketing channel can be weighed....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Strategy of Walt Disney Studios in Asia

It was founded in 1923, as an animation studio.... The paper 'Strategy of Walt disney Studios in Asia' presents Walt disney which is a well-known company, named after its owner, Walt disney.... hellip; The author of this paper states that Walt disney deals with a number of different products and services.... They are mainly into the animations, consumer products, and interactive studios, various stores that sell the Walt disney products like soft toys and many other products and merchandise for children....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Competitive Profile Matrix of Walt Disney

… The paper "Competitive Profile Matrix Walt disney" is a wonderful example of a management essay.... The Walt disney Company is leading not only to the international entertainment but also in the media enterprise.... The company operates five different disney segments: The Walt disney Studios, disney Interactive, Parks and Resorts, Media Networks, and disney Consumer Products.... The paper "Competitive Profile Matrix Walt disney" is a wonderful example of a management essay....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us