StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Roadside Memorials and Shrines - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Roadside Memorials and Shrines" states that it is essential to state that roadside memorials, which mark the sites of fatal accidents, have become controversial. Whether roadside memorials should be allowed or banned is a hot topic of debate. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Roadside Memorials and Shrines
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Roadside Memorials and Shrines"

?[Your full April 22, Roadside Memorials Roadside memorials, that mark the sites of fatal accidents, have become controversial. Whether roadside memorials should be allowed or banned is a hot topic of debate. On one side, roadside memorials store memories of loved ones for people, who tend them for months and years using flowers, religious symbols, and personal mementos; while on the other, they are a big distraction for drivers and road crews. They have also been criticized for improper display of religious symbols in public property. This argumentative paper argues that roadside memorials and shrines should be banned due to the dangers they pose to people, and also discusses some roadside memorials, whose images have been taken from internet search. MLA referencing style has been used properly, and the paper is summarized in a concluding paragraph. Tiernan, a lawyer in Colorado, says that the roadside memorials and shrines are “unconstitutional and a hazard” (para.3). According to him, there are three main reasons why roadside memorials should not be allowed to build and decorate. First of all, it is illegal to make use of public property to build shrines and memorials for private purposes. In other words, not an inch of public property can be used for private purposes without the consent of the owner, or court in case there is no owner. “…roadside memorials problematize some of our legal answers to debates about ownership, challenging our formal assumptions about the public-yet-anonymous nature of places like the highway or the street corner”, writes Wood (para.1). Hence, they are unconstitutional in this respect. Second, it is objectionable to use religious symbols like Christian crosses in roadside memorials. According to Tiernan, the use of religious symbols violates the constitution that demands separation of religion and state. Using religious symbols, like in figure 1, means promoting religion, and this is not allowed under constitution. Figure 1 shows a Christian cross as a memorial for a victim of a car accident on southbound I-684 in North Salem, New York. The cross has been decorated with flowers. Despite the fact that this roadside memorial is not big enough to cause distraction for drivers, yet it is making improper use of the Christian cross, which does not seem proper at public places. Third reason why roadside memorials should be banned, as asserted by Tiernan, is that they are a big distraction for the motoring public. A driver may get busy in reading the text about who got died, when, and how, written on the memorial, and may bump his car into something. And, if the drivers, for the sake of safety, are not supposed to slow down and read these memorials, then what is the point in building them at all? If the memorials are built on median strips along the highway, they are enough highly structured to be a disturbance for drivers. Also, if a driver loses the control of his car, and bumps into one of the symbols anchored into the ground, there are high chances that the driver will get seriously injured. Death may also occur from such an injury. Moreover, when mourners come to visit these roadside memorials to pray or leave flowers and mementos, they become a big annoyance for the traffic that may also get jammed, waiting for the mourners to clear up the way (see Figure 2). Roadside memorials become a bad sight for people when parts of them get stolen or broken. Figure 3 shows a broken Christian cross as a roadside memorial. When memorials with religious symbols break down, they not only become an unethical display of religious symbols, but also create a bad scene, which decreases the scenic beauty of the place. This makes them an eyesore rather than a pleasing memory. No doubt, there are other better ways of expressing love and respect to the deceased people, rather than making their deaths a source of constant annoyance for general public. Also, memorials decorated with stuffed toys and cartoon characters do not make sense at all. What is the point of mourning the death of a loved one by placing a teddy bear on the place of his death? It just does not make sense (see Figure 4). Clark (29-33) conducted a study on government policies about roadside memorials. According to her, government authorities are taking into consideration the building, maintenance and removal of roadside shrines and memorials due to the hazards that come with them. Government policies are being designed to limit the duration and type of memorials, and are considering removing them from crowded public places. Doss (391) has called it as memorial mania, because of the safety concerns. This memorial mania has made the issue of building and maintaining roadside shrines a controversial issue, both at individual and governmental level. Now, let’s have a look at a couple of roadside memorials, and focus on how they look like. Figure 5 shows a car decorated with flowers. This means that the victim died in a car accident. This memorial makes the family remember how the person died; and, for strangers, this memorial creates a terrifying impact. The negative effect that comes with it is that the onlooker might get terrified of driving, for good. Similarly, figure 6 shows a ghost-bike as a roadside memorial. This memorial means that the victim died while cycling. Although such memorials increase the aesthetic appeal of roadside, yet they tend to terrify people from driving and cycling. Summing it up together, roadside memorials are a hazard. They pose threat to drivers’ concentration upon road. They are also dangerous if drivers lose control of their cars and bump into them. They are not legal as they privatize the public property. They tend to disturb traffic flow. They make improper use of religious symbols, like the Christian cross. Broken memorials decrease the aesthetic appeal of the place. Considering all these hazards, it is recommended that government should take steps to remove and ban roadside memorials, once and for all; and, should discourage mourners to come on roads and annoy the traffic, instead of going to cemeteries for mourning. Figure 1: A roadside memorial to a victim of a car accident on southbound I-684 in North Salem, N.Y. Figure 2: Mourners are an annoyance for traffic < http://forums.vwvortex.com/showthread.php?5135612-Let-s-say-someone-put-a-roadside-memorial-in-your-front-yard.-.-./page2> Figure 3: Broken roadside memorial < http://tomeblen.bloginky.com/category/people/> Figure 4: Memorials not making sense http://photoartsmagazine.blogspot.com/2009_06_01_archive.html Figure 5: Roadside memorial car Figure 6: Roadside memorial ghost-bike < http://compleattraveller.blogspot.com/2011/09/new-york-city-ghost-bike.html> Works Cited Clark, Jennifer. “Views of the Verge: Roadside Memorials and Local Government Policies.” Journal of the Australasian College of Road Safety 18.2(2008): 29-33. Doss, Erika. Memorial Mania: Public Feeling in America. USA: University of Chicago Press, 2010. Tiernan, Robert. “Should Roadside Memorials be Banned?” The Opinion Pages. The New York Times, 2009. Web. 22 Apr 2012. . Wood, Andrew. “Should Roadside Memorials be Banned?” Woodland Shoppers Paradise. N.p., 2009. Web. 22 Apr 2012. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Roadside memorial Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1398012-research-paper
(Roadside Memorial Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1398012-research-paper.
“Roadside Memorial Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1398012-research-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Roadside Memorials and Shrines

Striking a Balance: The Debate over the Banning of Roadside Memorials

The ultimate alternative is the one commonly adopted by state governments: officially ban roadside memorials and get rid of them whenever they become unreasonably huge, plenty, or other operation is being carried out in the nearby area.... Churchill, A 2007, roadside memorials and Traffic Safety.... From the paper "Striking a Balance: The Debate over the Banning of roadside memorials" it is clear that permanent roadside memorials are needless objects on the thoroughfare and cause distraction, litter, confusion, and get in the way of pedestrians or bring about vehicular accidents....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Memorials and Museums in the USA

The paper "memorials and Museums in the USA" focuses on the fact that memorials and museums are visitor attractions that serve as public repositories of the past events and remembrance, each of which is inculcated with its distinct inevitable nature of memory.... Introduction memorials and museums are visitor attractions that serve as public repositories of the past events and remembrance, each of which is inculcated with its distinct inevitable nature of memory (Young, 1988)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

British Abstract Expressionism

This paper explores the influence and reception of British abstract expressionism.... Art is an expression of someone's feelings and emotions.... Every color and shape formed by an artist in his masterpiece speaks of his different thoughts and sentiments.... ... ... ... ... The aim of this study is to analyze British abstract expressionism....
25 Pages (6250 words) Coursework

London Ships of Historic Interest Partnership

From the paper "London Ships of Historic Interest Partnership" it is clear that if there are employees who are uncooperative in actions aimed at achieving organizational objectives then the management should take strict action against them as a warning to the rest of the organization's employees....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Death and Bereavement Within the Point of View of Roadside Memorials in the Book

It gives diverse insights on the local's interpretation of the installation of roadside memorials and its practical implication for them.... roadside memorials and Traffic Safety.... It gives diverse insights on the locals' interpretation of the installation of roadside memorials and its practical implication for them.... The paper "Death and Bereavement Within the Point of View of roadside memorials in the Book" analyze to understand the importance of roadside memorials....
7 Pages (1750 words) Annotated Bibliography

Reynoldss Views of Ise Shrine

This essay focuses on the shrine at Ise, Reynolds argues that unlike other Japanese shrines, Ise Shrine has remained culturally important after World War II.... Reynolds's Views of Ise ShrineIn his essay on the shrine at Ise, Reynolds argues that unlike other Japanese shrines, Ise Shrine has remained relevant and culturally important after World War II....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Cathedral Basilica of St. Peter and Paul

Examples of sacred building are prayer rugs, tallit's and Torah scrolls, altars or objects, shrines, roadside memorials and other portable sacred spaces for prayer, sacrifice, etc.... shrines, temples and any other stationary fixtures housing sacred deeds mark sacred sites....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

PTSD During Afghanistan and Vietnam War

The paper "PTSD During Afghanistan and Vietnam War" discusses that the age, marital status, and other aspects were different corresponding to the Vietnam veterans in variation to the Afghan veterans.... For example, more Afghan soldiers were females whereas Vietnamese were mostly men.... ... ... ...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us