StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty" paper argues that through the respect of human life and human dignity, the international community has found death to be non-objective since it has no scientific backing on crimes deterrence rather than vengeance thus should be global…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty"

Death Penalty Introduction Amongst the most discussed issue in the modern life is capital punishment. With both the protagonists and antagonists giving various justifications for their stand, makes death issue a very controversial one. In the U.S.A, the latest case of the death penalty is the execution of Bonne Terre on April this year. From ancient America to the present Capital punishment has received mixed reactions with some in favour while others object to it. With the first victim of the death penalty taking place in 1607, the U.S.A had suspended capital punishment from 1972 before resuming it in 1976. The present day American public opinion about the death penalty is still diverse with each part giving justifications for its course of action. In Nations like India, It has death resulted in politics and resentment over criminal brutality. The latest research in South Africa shows that approximately 90% of the present generation are in favour of the death penalty owing to high crime levels and brutality. Grounds for capital punishment According to Kyle Gibson in his article on the significance of the death penalty. He argues that the death sentence must be used as a deterrence against the most heinous and inhuman crimes done in the U.S. He gives examples of the recent bombing during the Boston marathon that claimed several lives and the deranged shooter amongst others where people had suffered for no wrong. He further feels that the death penalty serves as justice to the citizens as well as a crime control mechanism (Gibson, Para. 1). Kyle in his article quotes recent opinion polls that indicated a majority of the Americans supported the administration of the death penalty despite the media’s swayed reporting that indicated majority to be in opposition to the death penalty. Kyle further feels that it’s necessary to administer capital punishment since it’s the final revenge mechanism for the victim and close relations. By use of this rationale, the suiting penalty for murder and life-threatening crimes should be capital punishment. Capital punishment has also been used as a means of getting revenge for the affected victims. This tends to provide lasting peace since the victim feels secure that the criminal won’t be walking around scot-free and maybe injure someone else (Gibson, paras. 3-5). Kyle further uses an economic approach where he feels that humans respond to incentives with relevance to the law. He states that sentencing someone to 30 years in prison has no deterring effect unlike the death penalty (Gibson, Para. 7). On the other hand, execution served as a corrective mechanism for protecting the society from repeat attacks with a higher success rate (Gibson, Para. 9).He had also observed that the majority of criminals on death row are naturally violent and inhumane often requiring to be placed in segregation. Thus for the good and safety of the prison warders, fellow inmates and the general society should a criminal break from jail. In the application of the consequential theory under utilitarian, it’s better to execute a criminal of such nature than suffer the consequences later. The cause and action will justify his/her execution (Gibson, Para.12). Through capital punishment the felons are prevented from doing further crimes thus saving the state resources hunting for the person again in case he/she was paroled (Gibson, Para. 13). Gibson argues that keeping a criminal in death row segregation for several years is inhuman as it results in tension and suffering as a consequence of the anticipation. This in return makes the suffering more severe than executing the criminal at once. Since it’s ethical to promote euthanasia in medicine, it’s also ethical to hasten a criminal’s death rather than allow several complicated non-production years behind bars in segregation. In the case of a paedophile or mass murders, there is an unwritten policy that other inmates make your life a living hell. Despite the paedophile being slapped with a death sentence, he will spend a good number of years behind bars. For his protection, he will have to be housed in solitary confinement but in case fellow inmates got to him he may end up dying before his execution time reaches (Gibson, Para. 8-10). Reasons Against the death Penalty According to Al Sharpton, human rights activities have for very long lobbied for the abolishment of the capital punishment globally. They have come out strongly to term it inhuman since it violates a person’s right to live. They argue that even though the offender may have committed murder on his part, two wrongs won’t make a right. The human right activists have gone further to term execution as painful and barbaric despite methods being used to ease the pain being applied. These activists believe that life imprisonment on its own is punishment enough to a criminal in comparison to the death. As a result of inadequate judicial and policing system in conducting investigations, most capital penalty victims are usually innocent only to be later proved innocent when it’s too late. It has caused. As a result, execution of people for crimes they never committed in their lives. Several religious scholars hold the belief that by executing someone shall amount to blasphemy through playing God. According to them, Death should be natural since because the lord is the one who can author and terminate life. On the other hand, other religions believe that the death of its part is part of nature and should not be justified in executing someone else. Theologises have further argued that executed felons have limited times and the likelihood of reconciling their wrong ways and getting spiritual salvation. While philosophers like Niccolo Machiavelli felt that that religion and salvation are not issues of concern to the state. Whenever capital punishment is applied to an individual, his family members, and immediate kin suffer in both emotionally and financially. The families of the murder victims as well as the criminals family both experience for a considerable long period due to elongated legal procedure that includes having to testify and re-testify in court severally which is like reopening the wound. On the felon’s part, his kin endure seeing him daily in the hope that he is going to be freed until when judgement is passed. This prolonged legal extends the agony experienced by the victim’s families. The major contributor in determining if a defendant will be subjected to the capital punishment or not is the quality of legal representation he is provided with in court. In the case of Coker vs. Georgia his legal defence argued that only poor men and those who lacked adequate legal backing were subjected to capital punishment thus terming it as discriminative and inhuman (Sharpton, Paras. 1-5). It was also discovered that race was a contributing factor towards the administration of capital punishment. According to the U.S office of Accounting, those who murdered or committed grievous offences to white people were most likely to receive the death penalty as compared to killing coloured people. It was also discovered that more coloured people were sent to the gallows unlike the white people (Sharpton, Paras. 6-8). The international community with the majority of Europe and American countries have abolished capital punishment. With the total number of states in the death sentence rising day steadily as a result of international pressure, its time the death penalty was done away with Common Ground Although both groups have divergent views on the issue of Death penalty, both sides agree that the inclusion of capital punishment into the judicial system does not in any way deter crime nor reduce crime rates. This is because grievous crimes that fit death are still rife in countries that practice capital punishment unlike those that don’t. As a result of these observations, capital punishment should be done away with. My Position My view with concern to this topic is the elimination of capital punishment since it lacks judicial or legal objectivity but rather oppression and discrimination of people. Through manipulation of the law, most individuals with an active legal defence have managed to evade capital punishment and majority of people convicted of murder charges have later been found to be innocent. The overturned conviction is coming in rather late in life can never be. In addition, death penalty denies a criminal the chance to change to become a good citizen. It also subject the family members to suffering especially if the offender was a bread winner his/her children may even drop out of school as there is no one to take care of their needs. Therefore, I would strongly urge the government for the removal of death penalty. Conclusion After a careful consideration of the reasons for and against capital punishment, both the antagonist and protagonists agree that the death penalty does not in any way serve as deterrence towards crime. This is this is because crime rates in countries that still subject criminals to capital punishment have higher crime rates compared to those that do not (Sharpton, para.5).Through the respect of human life and human dignity, the international community has found death to be non-objective since it has no scientific backing on crimes deterrence rather than vengeance thus should be globally. Work cited Al Sharpton. ‘The Death Penalty Must Go’ Retrieved from < http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rev-al-sharpton/the-death-penalty-must-go_b_5268594.html> Web. 12 Dec 2014 Gibson, Kyle. Death Penalty Repeal: It is Necessary to Use Capital Punishment in a Free World.Mic. Nap. 2013. Web. 12 Dec. 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1852942-presents-a-debated-issue-in-contemporary-politics-and-identifies-common-ground
(Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1852942-presents-a-debated-issue-in-contemporary-politics-and-identifies-common-ground.
“Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1852942-presents-a-debated-issue-in-contemporary-politics-and-identifies-common-ground.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Debated Issue in Contemporary Politics: Death Penalty

Death Penalty

death penalty- Should we abolish Capital punishment?... In 1723, the Waltham Black Acts was passed in the Parliament in which many new crimes were ratified and this augmented the number of people given the death penalty every year.... n 1750s the reforms for death penalty begin to integrate in Europe and were under the governance of Cesare Beccaria (an Italian jurist), Voltaire (a French Philospher) and law reformers from England such as Samuel Romilly and Jeremy Bentham....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The American System of Criminal Justice - Death Penalty Should be Abolished

This paper "The American System of Criminal Justice - death penalty Should be Abolished" focuses on the death penalty has gone through severe criticism and opposition in the recent years, and one of the most debated topics in connection with this issue has been whether or not the death penalty should be abolished.... nbsp;… Significantly, the debate concerning death penalty has become one of the most long-lasting and exciting debates in politics and criminal justice today....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Controversy that Surrounds Capital Punishment

Introduction The application of the death penalty has remained a controversial issue in contemporary societies, as it has continued to attract heated debates both from opponents and proponents without the hope of reaching a consensus (McCafferty 17).... This code contained 282 laws that governed that society, with more than twenty-five of these laws advocating for the death penalty as a punishment for the crimes committed.... It may be important to note that the United States at this time was under the colonial rule of the Britons, who are credited with the introduction of the death penalty in the pre-independence era....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Whether the Death Penalty is a Desirable Policy

An issue touching on a policy relating to death penalty brings to mind the fundamental rights and freedoms of human being (Coughlin, 2004, p.... hellip; Whether the death penalty is A Desirable Policy.... An issue touching on a policy relating to death penalty brings to mind the fundamental rights and freedoms of human being (Coughlin, 2004, p.... Apparently, death penalty is a controversial debate, with both opposing camps presenting strong positions aimed at justifying their claim....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Evaluation of Capital Punishment as a Method of Crime Control in the USA

Global perspectives allow opportunity to trace the occurrence of the death penalty and the application of capital punishment with respect to the changeover from customary to the contemporary societies.... For example, in the Chinese criminal justice system, with its unmistakable dependence upon the death penalty, it bears the impression of many conventional Chinese legal norms and values (Nisbett, 1993).... The deterrence from crime, a factor argued by advocates of the death penalty, is not promoted by capital punishment....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Post-Ruth Ellis: Changing Attitudes to Crime and Punishment in Britain

In 1963, a couple of years before the Murder (Abolition of death penalty) Act 1965 suspended the death penalty for murder, Robert Hancock published Ruth Ellis: The Last Woman to be Hanged.... 6Nevertheless, it may be noted that even in 1965, when the UK Parliament resolved to end the death penalty, public opinion largely seemed to be in favour of keeping it probably because conventional thinking would lead us to believe that capital punishment could be a deterrent to murder....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Catholic Church on Death Penalty

This paper 'The Catholic Church on death penalty" focuses on the fact that the Catholic Church vehemently resist the implementation of the death penalty.... nbsp; … In several countries, the death penalty has had a short life as a way of administering justice.... Some countries do not listen to the clamour of ending the death penalty and not a few people have tasted death.... It is a matter of active controversy in various countries and states, and positions can vary within a single political ideology or cultural region…Today, most countries are considered by Amnesty International as abolitionists, which allowed a vote on a nonbinding resolution to the UN to promote the abolition of the death penalty....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Vanderbilt Law School debate on the Death penalty

death penalty is a severe measure, which various activists have… The debate reveals that there are numerous errors in the justice system that has resulted in the execution of innocent individuals.... According to the proponents of this Owing to the above details provided, the opponent of death penalty, Dr.... death penalty is not only about liberal or conservative politics but also about the moral choices of this nation.... This dispels any notion that the death penalty debate is about conservative and liberal politics....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us