StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Elements Surrounding Human Lives - Literature review Example

Summary
This paper "The Elements Surrounding Human Lives" tells that for thousands of centuries. Bright minds have been navigating outside the reaches of human knowledge. The question of the meaning of life is actually a dead-end. It is just convenient to accept that our physical frameworks can grasp things…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
The Elements Surrounding Human Lives
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Elements Surrounding Human Lives"

The faculty of wonder that developed in the psyche of myriads of brilliant philosophers primarily arose due to the concern on truth and the meaning of life. Friedrich Nietzsche, an extremely profound thinking philosopher, claimed that the elements surrounding human lives are dynamic and not absolute; so, in seeking for the truth, one must not consider origin but instead contemplate on the genealogy of morality. Fabricated truths of morality produced by religion, according to Nietzsche, are fixed and grounded on a finite meaning and essence, which are not in actual reality. Morality, just like how Darwin described human evolution, is a fluid and adaptive concept. A gifted philosopher of the postmodern period, John Cottingham, argued against the premises put forth by Nietzsche on the arbitrariness of the meaning of life. Cottingham believed that the things and meanings that go beyond human understanding are actually knowable controlled and manipulated by an omniscient agency or force. Human existence in relation to the immense universe can be explained by an absolute truth. He cleverly contended that the Darwinian evolutionary theory had been applied to every facet of human life thus removing the leeway of having a permanent and supreme answer to questions such as “Why are we here?”, “What is my life’s purpose?” thus eliminating the importance of obedience to dogmatic morality. In his book entitled On the Meaning of Life, Cottingham addressed specific scientists such as Aristotle to denote that scientific knowledge drastically replaced teleology in its preeminence in explaining the meaning of human existence. Unlike Nietzsche, who was labeled as an existentialist, Cottingham strongly believed in Hume and Descarte’s assumption that a Supreme Being purposively concealed unfathomable meanings beneath the visible natural and physical world (Cottingham p. 6). These buried meanings are essentially pinpointing the fundamental nature of human existence. For Cottingham, a meaningful life is attainable only if individuals will align themselves to established moral codes. Meanings that are unknowable can be possibly grasped only through humans’ effort to realize their moral objectives. Moreover, he fervently believed that a solitary all-powerful and invincible entity would extend a hand to uphold order among all vital things in the world so that humans will appreciate the need to strengthen one’s goal towards a moral life, which is also meaningful. Cottingham detests Nihilism and meaning based on the evolution of humanity which Nietzsche promoted for the belief that only an absolute moral principle has the power to bestow meaning to life; in simple words, morality that is strictly anchored on the teachings of God (Metz p. 259). Nevertheless, Cottingham attempted to take into consideration the life of those people who chose to live in accordance to their animalistic instinct, which is being aggressive and egotistical at the absence of restraints. He pondered whether this immoral kind of life, exemplified by his concept of the “committed torturer”, has the right to become meaningful. Rather than directly answering the question, Cottingham stated that a meaningful human life is an open and integrated one whereas the life of a corrupt such as the torturer is most likely torn apart. He then goes on to say that a meaningful life must at all cost follow the path drawn for humans to traverse and not the trail of remote individual choices (Cottingham 2003). On the contrary, Nietzsche maintains that the true meaning of life does not lie on the mercy of an unseen and immeasurable Supreme spirit; instead, he eloquently argued that morality, just like humans for Darwin, evolve in a gradual manner. This morality confers meaning to human existence; yet, before meanings would emerge, existence must first materialize. Nietzsche, unlike Cottingham, did not believe in God. He contested the belief that prior to human life there were already well-built meanings embedded in the natural and the spiritual worlds. Nietzsche would definitely defend himself against the criticisms of Cottingham by reiterating his original standpoint on the significance of morality. The concept of Nihilism that Cottingham largely loathes was actually plainly defined by Nietzsche as the complete rejection of moral standard in the modern world. Reading excerpts from Nietzsche’s philosophical treatises would most probably give a first impression that he advocated for the abolishment of moral principles. Yet, just like Cottingham, Nietzsche supported the survival of morality through a precise understanding of its genealogical origins. He merely desired to clarify that morality played a different role at different times; that a meaningful life is relevant to the dominant moral codes of the incumbent period. On the other hand, regarding Cottingham’s notion of the committed torturer, Nietzsche perceived immoral acts as a form of strength and power. In his essays, Nietzsche described two kinds of morality: the “knightly-aristocratic” and the “priestly” or “slave”. He defined the former as a type of morality that characterized rulers and conquerors whilst the latter is portrayed by the act of self-denial (Nietzsche sec 6-7). For Nietzsche, slave morality is not productive since it removes humans away from their true form or capabilities by stressing on the wickedness of others. Suppressing individuals’ inner self, or their human nature, is a sign of weakness. People in a self-denial process not only inhibit their fullest potentials but also stagnate their movement towards a meaningful life. So logically, following this premise, it is safe to assume that Nietzsche thought that a committed torturer is in reality living a good life since that person did not consciously suppressed his/her inner life but instead obeyed the calling of the self’s yearning. Likewise, Nietzsche presumed that morality is dictated by the will to power of those who are strong enough to coerce their will to another being. The interpretation of what is good and what is evil is substantially associated to the will that has the greatness to bend it towards a particular meaning. For instance, the idea of “good” had been governed by the barbarians who emanated strength and fine health and the opposite which is evil had been awarded to those who chose to live a life of mediocrity (Nietzsche sec 2). During this time, a committed torturer would definitely be considered a morally upright individual considering the fact that the “good” barbarians were notorious in their cruel and brutal acts. But if placed in the contemporary period, the torturer would absolutely be condemned and consigned to capital punishment because of his/her unlawful and immoral behavior. To simply put it, Nietzsche argued that there are myriads of ways in looking at a particular phenomenon which could be considerably swayed by the will to power of the powerful. In this essence, Nietzsche maintained that the constant ticking of the clock produced both communal interests and individualistic pursuits that interchange as morality evolve (Gaarder p. 377). Nietzsche’s defense against Cottingham’s God-based morality is successful at two levels. First, he was able to balance his criticisms against morality by stating that he is not on the abolition of moral standards but instead he simply advocated a clear understanding of the surfacing of morality so that individuals would have a profound thought on how to attain a meaningful life. Secondly, he expressively marked the difference between a powerful and feeble life by distinguishing a subsistence that is allied with the individual personas and one that is fastened on self-defiance or the suppression of the inner self. For thousands of centuries, bright minds have been navigating outside the reaches of the human knowledge. The question on the meaning of life is actually a dead-end. It is just convenient to accept that what our physical frameworks can grasp are the things that pertain to the meaning surrounding our reality. Those that we cannot perceive are rather interesting but the fact that multitudes of the great minds who worked on tirelessly to acquire the answer to these surreal entities just generated more questions than answers is a vivid proof that humans have limits. Just like Nietzsche and Cottingham, the quest for the answer to the meaning of life did not yield any luck, but instead generated vibrant discourses among the world’s remarkable thinkers throughout time. Works Cited Books Cottingham, John. On the Meaning of Life. London: Routledge, 1993. Gaarder, Jostein. Sophies World. New York: Farrar, Strauss, & Giroux Inc., 1991. Online Sources Metz, Thaddeus. Baier and Cottingham on the Meaning of Life. South Africa: University of Witwatersrand, viewed 26 June 2008. http://disputatio.com/articles/019-4.pdf Nietzsche, Friedrich. On the Genealogy of Morals. Leipzig, 1887. http://records.viu.ca/~johnstoi/Nietzsche/genealogytofc.htm Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Elements Surrounding Human Lives

The Painting Reclining Woman on the Beach

There are many elements of design present that touch on similar topics to the elements of form.... It also touches on themes of beauty, of the unique visual nature of each individual human, and of the soft, changing mutability of human nature in contrast to the... It is one of Pablo Picasso's earliest works, and contains many elements that are both similar and different from the cubism that would make him famous in years to come....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Key elements from the philosophies of Hegel and Husserl

According to this theory, human beings are free to determine what they are, what they want to do, and/or what is important for them.... human beings are free to determine their nature and act accordingly.... In a nutshell, according to existentialism, human beings are not influenced by external factors in determining their choices and actions.... Hegel was also of the same opinion albeit he put forth certain conditions or situations when human beings have this kind of free will....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Learning to Teach through Journalism

hen a worker deals with the surrounding environment they are affected upon and affected upon and this is directly proportional or inversely proportional according to the manner that the environment is dealt with and how the worker is dealt with.... Also, the manner of handling the money is a manner of character that provides the background of how the fact of dealing with such material could reflect the person's personality on how to behave with money and consequently the surrounding and the effect of money upon them....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Death in Greek Myth as Divine and Human

As death talks, not only is it seen that this is a divine entity that is able to take the lives of those who are ready to die, but also plays with the lives of those that are about to die for respect and for status among the other gods.... The paper "Death in Greek Myth as Divine and human" provides an understanding that the concept of death in Greek myth is one that relates to the religious and cultural views of the time.... When looking at the different concepts of death, there is an understanding that it is a part of the divine while there are other elements that show a perspective that is human....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Franklin Lloyd Wright

Wright was very conscious of the natural surrounding and worked wherever he could to encourage the idea that this is a natural outgrowth of the forest, perfectly suited to the living needs of another of nature's creations – humans.... According to the writer, the interior of the home reflects the symbiosis with nature and provides the essential elements of a weekend home....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Fallingwater created by Franklin Lloyd Wright

This research paper describes the history of the Fallingwater created by Franklin Lloyd Wright.... This paper outlines the modernism of Franklin Lloyd Wright, the history of creating, the building and its special features, the role of nature and philosophy of the fallingwater.... ... ... ... His name is synonymous with the very highest in architectural achievement....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Reclining Woman on the Beach

here are many elements of design present that touch on similar topics to the elements of form.... This painting does what it sets out to do incredibly effectively, and fully lives up to its potential.... This essay "Reclining Woman on the Beach" sheds some light on one of Pablo Picasso's earliest works and contains many elements that are both similar and different from the cubism that would make him famous in years to come.... The coloration in the two main elements are also vastly different – the woman is predominantly pale or pearly but has many dashes of different colors throughout her body, that fade in and out gradually – green in some places, purple in others, and so on....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Notion of Virtual Reality

For a fact, what they present is a complete related dimension and serves to offer insights on the nature of humans and their lives in relation to the working of their minds.... The intellects on the human mind and human experience give accounts that provoke a keen look to identify which of them are full baked or which is thought-provoking.... It is a superficial thing with no effect on the inner composition of the human beings....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us