StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley's Idealism, and a Comparison with Platonic Formalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Prof’s Name Date The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythic Account of Berkley’s Idealism, and a Comparison with Platonic Formalism Philosophical ideas can often be nearly impossible to understand for a lay (or even a learned) audience upon first reading, and sometimes second, third or fourth reading…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkleys Idealism, and a Comparison with Platonic Formalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley's Idealism, and a Comparison with Platonic Formalism"

Download file to see previous pages

In this allegory, he talks about the fact that if all we could perceive were shadows of objects cast on a cave wall, we could still perceive many things about their existence, and they would be, to us, at least in some ways, real, even though they are mere shadows of the things that actually truly exist (Plato 229). He uses this to explain his concept of formalism, in which objects we see are mere reflections of a higher realm of those objects – for instance, we can cognitively assume that there is such thing as a perfect isosceles triangle (with infinitely thin lines, perfect angles, exact measurements and so on).

Yet we also know that any representation of that triangle that we have ever seen is imperfect – one line might be an atom or two too long, the way the pen catches the paper could create distortions and so on. This is, in its fundamentals, the philosophical concept known as Platonic Formalism. George Berkeley’s conception of reality, known as Subjective Idealism, differs from Plato’s in several important ways. This essay will first attempt to create a myth or allegory to explain Berkeley’s idealism, then move on to compare and contrast it with platonic formalism.

George Berkeley’s understanding of reality essentially, in its most basic form, states that the only two things that exists are “spirits” and “ideas” (Berkeley 81). Though it can be difficult to translate these ideas into modern terminology, the crux of what he means by these two terms is essential the thinking or conscious mind, and the things that this mind perceives. It sounds as if this might be similar to fundamental skepticism (that you only know that you exist – cognito ergo sum), but this is not in fact the case.

This is not necessarily to deny the existence of material things per se, but indicates that their existence is limited as they are understood by a conscious mind – thus an object’s existence does not really come into account when it is not perceived. He combines this all together with a dose of theology, indicating that God has a wider perception than other spirits, and thus provides existence for many things, possibly including people, and forms a sort of group consciousness (87). Now that the basics of his principles have been set out, I will attempt to explain them with a myth or allegory, in the form of a though experiment.

First there was nothing, only a consciousness that did not have outside materials to understand or work on. In its boredom, the consciousness conceived of the idea of a place to house itself, and imagined itself as suspended in a physical body. This consciousness has incredible powers of imagination – so to it, it suddenly inhabited a body. Now, to what extent is this body real? If the only thing that truly exists in the universe is a consciousness, and this consciousness feels or knows that it inhabits this body, then in what way can that body be unreal?

The only determiner of reality that exists calls it real: thus a body is born. Now imagine that this consciousness meats another consciousness – and perceives that it too is clothed in a body. Now the question remains: where does this new consciousness exist? It exists certainly in one place: in the mind of the original consciousness. The second consciousness then acts in an unexpected way – it walks into a house. The first consciousness had never

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley's Essay”, n.d.)
The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley's Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1451341-metaphysics-by-tim-crane-and-katalin-farkas
(The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley'S Essay)
The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley'S Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1451341-metaphysics-by-tim-crane-and-katalin-farkas.
“The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley'S Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1451341-metaphysics-by-tim-crane-and-katalin-farkas.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Cave and the Consciousness: A Mythlic Account of Berkley's Idealism, and a Comparison with Platonic Formalism

Gottfried Leibniz-Consciousness and Unconsciousness

The paper "Gottfried Leibniz-consciousness and Unconsciousness" looks for discussing with special reference to the contributions made by French philosopher Rene Descartes and eminent eighteenth-century German thinker Gottfried Leibniz while elaborating the same.... hellip; Although state of sleep and philosophy of unconsciousness has always been a matter of vital interest for the thinkers and philosophers since ever, yet the issue got particular attention of the discipline of philosophy during 17th and 18th centuries....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation Formalism vs Realism

The Constitution and Problems of Interpretation formalism vs Realism Name Institution In 1881, legal realism started following the publishing of the ‘Common Law' by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.... Conversely, legal formalism is a rule and law-based perception of decision-making.... Present day legal formalism is especially prominent within two parts, constitutional law together with statutory interpretation (Tamanaha, 2009).... According to the constitutional law, formalism is integrated with “originalism,” the perception that the constitution has to be interpreted in concurrence with its “original meaning....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Formalist and Expressionist Concepts of Art

In the paper “Formalist and Expressionist Concepts of Art” the author examines the influence of two of the most dominant perspectives in art, formalism and expressionism, on both artists and viewers alike as represented in the works of Caravaggio, Eduoard Manet, Barnet Newman, and Norman Rockwell.... hellip; The author states that formalism is one of the most influential concepts underpinning artistic theory and practice.... nbsp;The influence of formalism on artists and their work is particularly evident in the paintings of the old masters....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Realism vs Idealism: Liberal Institutionalism

In the current paper "Realism vs idealism: Liberal Institutionalism", an author will summarize and evaluate the two main theories of international relations covered in the text: realism and idealism.... hellip; It is by far more sensible and effectual to execute around idealism whose moral behavior overcomes the rigidity and narrowness of power politics confined in the realist approach.... idealism (“Liberal Institutionalism”) It is by far more sensible and effectual to execute around idealism whose moral behavior overcomes the rigidity and narrowness of power politics confined in the realist approach....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Idealism in Epistemology and Theories of Idealism

Different idealists have a different perception regarding how the substance is dependent on the consciousness.... Therefore there are many diverse types of idealism.... Subjective idealism is mainly simple and it can be said that this type of idealism is the most popular type of idealism.... Subjective idealism might look a bit odd although there is the existence of definite reasoning behind it....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Formalism Criticism Issues

CharacteristicsIn conducting a literary analysis, the following key characteristics will be associated with formalism criticism: tension, intentional fallacy, affective fallacy, external form and objective correlative.... In the novel water for elephants the structure and syntax were used for formalism criticism in this paper....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Pol 211 Mile 2 Realism, idealism

Idealists view the state as a means of Key Factors of Realism and idealism KEY FACTORS OF REALISM AND idealism Key Factors of Realism and idealism of nature, anarchy, and war Nations exist in a state known as chaos where war between nations was permanent and expected.... The collapse of the Soviet Union is best described using the realism and idealism concept of “Balance of Power”....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The English School between Realism and Idealism

"The English School between Realism and idealism" paper discusses the contributions brought by realism, idealism, and the English school of international relations to the international relations theory field.... nbsp;  Several questions exist that must be answered when comparing realism, idealism, and the English school.... This happened through criticizing the liberal idealism through the interwar period.... n the other hand, idealism is regarded as the theory that guides international relations that were always being viewed as the opposite of realism....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us