StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper analyses the actions of a killer who, due to police’s incompetence, lived a free life and this led to the Boston catastrophe. The aim of the paper is to help to avoid the errors of the police system in future, to reduce the chances of Americans meeting their untimely deaths…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System"

 On April 15, 2013, Americans witnessed one of the most shocking incidents in their country’s history. Two bombs detonated at the Boston Marathon that resulted to three deaths and more than 200 injuries. The two bombs were safely planted near the finish line, 600 feet apart on the northern side of Boylston Street. The first bomb went off at around 2:50 PM, 12 seconds later the second bomb also exploded. The medical tent that was meant to treat runners was converted to an emergency facility to treat the victims. However, three succumbed to the injuries while scores of people were maimed and injured. The Boston Police together with other investigators began a manhunt for the suspects behind the attack. Video footages and photographs were solicited from the public to assist in the investigations. Reports reveal the bombs were homemade. They comprised pressure cookers filled with ball bearings, nails and explosive substances. The Federal Bureau of Investigation revealed the photos of the men who were considered prime suspects plus a photo showing one of them planting a bomb at the place where it went off. Hours later, there was a fatal shooting of a campus police and an armed robbery of a vehicle in Cambridge. (Ray, 2013) The police concluded that there was a connection between the two crimes and so, they pursued the stolen vehicle. At Watertown, the police marooned the criminal and a fierce shootout began. The criminal was eventually wounded and his identity revealed as Tamerlan Tsarnaev, one of the suspects connected with the bombings. He succumbed to the multiple gunshot wounds. Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, his younger brother successfully fled the scene. The police began the manhunt from house to house and this resulted to a curfew; no one was allowed to leave his/her houses and all businesses had to be closed down. However, the curfew was removed at around 6:00 PM, few hours later Dzhokhar was located and arrested. He had been hiding in a boat in a backyard. He is still awaiting trial and could face up to a death penalty when found guilty. The story may have ended well, but there are errors that the Boston Police did that really questions the ability of the law enforcers to protect their citizens. First of all, during their yard to yard search for Dzhokhar, they did not look into the boat which was in their vicinity. A boat with a cover on top should have raised suspicion and would have been the first place to search when they entered the yard, but somehow a group of trained men in uniform wielding very dangerous weapons did not seem to think that something may be hiding in there and were it for the courage of an old man the suspect would not have been caught. Failure to look into the boat shows carelessness on their part. Furthermore, they opened rounds in a neighborhood causing severe damages to the residents’ houses. Even though no deaths or injuries were reported, but it was sheer lack that innocent victims were not hurt. An interview carried out by The Boston Globe in the neighborhood revealed that most people are still living in horror after the incident which occurred more than six months ago. Olga Ciuc and her husband Dumitru are unable to sleep in their bedroom after their house had been smeared by countless bullets. They are not the only ones, Lori and her family had to shift from their house due to fear of another shooting incident. (Abel, 2013) What is shocking is that the police opened fire as soon as they reached the backyard after they had been tipped by the boat’s owner. There was no retaliation from the young man nor did he shoot first. In fact, he did not have any gun at all, but the police decided to shoot first. This is a wrong of handling the situation. The main point is the police are not allowed to shoot unless a criminal attacks them first. Dzhokhar did not attack anyone; he was just lying down scared. He may have committed the atrocious bombings earlier on, but at this point he was so harmless to the extent that he did not attack the old man when he first came to the boat. (Friedersdorf, 2013) Going by these facts, opening fire first showed cowardice among the police. The best action would have been to order the boy to throw away any weapon he had and come out with his hand raised. None of this happened; if it did the witnesses would have said it in the report. Furthermore, opening rounds aimlessly in a residential estate was unacceptable. Women and children could have been killed or wounded. The aftermath of this action is that people are still living in fear and horror several months after the incident had occurred. The work of the police is to protect lives and not to endanger them. There is also the issue of the lockdown. Most people and critics believe that the curfew resulted in more fear and hysteria among the people. The lockdown does not represent any form of security, but rather shows a militarized type of situation where the police are in control of and the people have to obey all their commands. It is true that the lockdown took away the civil liberties of the Boston residents and replaced it with an authoritarian system only present in dictatorial governments. Moreover, it was not effective and it was after the lockdown had been called off that Dzhokhar was arrested. (Giroux, 2013) The lockdown policy is not the right method to fight acts of terrorism. First of all, it puts many lives in danger. A very sick person that needs immediate medical attention may die because all medical facilities have been closed. Secondly, shutting down the all town may actually work in favor of the criminals. They will be aware of everything that the police will be doing and they will act to counter that. But, if everything continued normally, then the police would be unpredictable and this would make the criminals more and more unsettled. Denying people the right to move about would only lead to resentment of the police force and most people would not cooperate. The lockdown mirrors the notion of a police state where constitutional rights, freedoms and privileges of the people are directly controlled by the police. Most terrorist attacks do not occur over night, they are carefully planned for months or even years before the attack occurs. This is where the authorities especially the FBI went wrong. A year earlier before the attacks, Tamerlan was involved in so many suspicious activities that should have made the authorities to monitor all his moves. There have been speculations that Tamerlan took a six months hiatus to Dagestan, where he met with Muslim extremists. The Russian intelligence confirmed this, but the American intelligence brushed them aside and claimed there were no concrete evidences to support that. Russians also discovered electronic communication between the bomber and a Russian extremist William Plotnikov in Canada. This information was also brushed aside by the FBI. According to the Russian intelligence, Mahmoud Mansour Nidal recruited Tamerlan in Dagestan. Media sources in the area also support this claim. However, American experts still refuted this claim and asserted that if Tamerlan had indeed gone to Dagestan, he could not have returned to American without interrogation from the Russians. Then, there is the controversial issue of Todashev. The FBI claim that he was on the verge of admitting that Tamerlan was his accomplice in a triple homicide that occurred in 2011 at Waltham, before he was gunned down. During the murder investigations, investigators found that there was no sign of forced entry and the $5000 found in the apartment showed that it was not a robbery either. They concluded that the murderers and the victims knew each other. Mess, one of the victims was Tamerlan’s best friend. The irony of the matter is that Tamerlan was never interrogated and the case was never solved until the day he died. Putting all these factors into perspective, it seems that Tamerlan was a dangerous person and the American intelligence had a clue of this. Failure to question Tamerlan during the Waltham homicides was the biggest mistake the authorities made. He could have been found guilty and the Boston bombings would not have occurred. What is sickening is that the investigators had substantial evidence to prove that a close friend carried out the atrocities, but still refused to interrogate one of the victims’ best friend. That is very unprofessional. Even if he could not be found guilty and walked away, the authorities would have known the type of person he was and would have kept a close eye on him. Russian intelligence had also tipped the American authorities of Tamerlan’s suspicious trips to Dagestan. Though it was foolishness on the Russian’s part not to interrogate him, the American intelligence should not have ignored their warnings. They should have kept a close watch over the man and even tapped his phone and computer if need be. They could have uncovered so much. For instance, the communication between him and Plotnikov could have been intercepted. Reports by the FBI reveal that the two brothers learnt how to make bombs from an Al Qaeda website. Had their internet connections been intercepted, then the intelligence would have known their intentions. Every American is entitled to all rights and freedoms enshrined in the Constitution. However, the rights may be taken if it is proven that a person is a threat to humanity. Tamerlan acted suspiciously in many ways that it was quite clear that he was planning something heinous. The intelligence would have intercepted his phone and PC connections and monitored all his movements, even if it violates all his rights as a citizen. He was already a killer, but due to police’s incompetence, he lived a free life and this led to the Boston catastrophe. The whole incident, stemming from Tamerlan’s trips to Dagestan, to the triple homicide of his friends up to the Boston’s bombings is dotted with so many errors to the extent that Americans are not confident enough with their police system. These errors have to be avoided in future, to reduce chances of Americans meeting their untimely deaths. References 1. Abel, David (Oct. 16, 2013). Boat owner seeks to clarify record on Tsarnaev capture. Retrieved from http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/10/15/six-months-later-man-who-found-dzhokhar-tsarnaev-his-boat-tries-move/fMSWzruQfE2EUNYXjXKOZP/story.html 2. Bergen, Peter & Rowland, Jennifer (Apr. 8, 2014). Four things we learned about the Boston bombing. Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2014/04/08/opinion/bergen-boston-bombing-five-things/. 3. Friedersdorf, Conor (Oct. 17, 2013). The Alarming Mistakes Police Made after the Boston Bombing. Retrieved from http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/10/the-alarming-mistakes-police-made-after-the-boston-bombing/280635/. 4. Giroux, Henry (May 6, 2013). Lockdown, USA: Lessons from the Boston Marathon Manhunt. Retrieved from http://truth-out.org/opinion/item/16175-lockdown-usa-lessons-from-the-boston-marathon-manhunt. 5. Ray, Michael (May 8, 2013). Boston Marathon Bombing of 2013. Retrieved from http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/1924021/Boston-Marathon-bombing-of-2013 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System Case Study, n.d.)
April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1819120-april-15-boston-marathon-bombing
(April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System Case Study)
April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/1819120-april-15-boston-marathon-bombing.
“April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1819120-april-15-boston-marathon-bombing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF April 15 Boston Marathon Bombing: The Errors of the US Police System

Death Penalty Punishment for Boston Marathon Survivor

Name Course Instructor Date Death Penalty as Punishment for boston marathon Survivor INTRODUCTION Certain serious crimes raise concerns for all the people to take the charge for their crimes.... … Name Course Instructor Date Death Penalty as Punishment for boston marathon Survivor INTRODUCTION Certain serious crimes raise concerns for all the people to take the charge for their crimes.... Death Penalty as Punishment for boston marathon Survivor INTRODUCTION Certain serious crimes raise concerns for all the people to take the charge for their crimes....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Strategic bombing campaign

The present essay "Strategic bombing campaign" is focused on the strategic bombing campaign during World War II.... hellip; Murray and Millet have summarized them by saying that “strategic bombing played a relatively unimportant part in winning World War II”.... In spite of this criticism, war analysts like Murray and Millet have pointed out certain impacts of strategic bombing campaign on the ability of Japan and Germany to wage war....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

8.25 / system errors

When such a period elapses, the system automatically logs out the user.... In case another person gets system Errors Grade May, 27, system Errors Two types of features can be used to prevent maladministration of drugs in a hospital computer system in case a doctor forgets to log out.... When such a period elapses, the system automatically logs out the user.... In case another person gets access to the computer system within the set period then the occurrence of an error will be inevitable....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Political Crime and/or Terrorism

The reign of terror acts coalesce around the extreme activities of Muslim extremists who believe that they have to cause havoc, panic, suffering and even death to fellow human beings on various reasons most of which I believe are… The boston marathon bombing as well as the consequent linked shootings comprised a succession of attacks that commenced on April 15, 2013; the day of the Boston Marathon.... The boston marathon bombing as well as the consequent linked shootings comprised a succession of attacks that commenced on April 15, 2013; the day of the Boston Marathon....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Criminal Justice class: [class title] Terrorism & Homeland Security--Assignment: Defining Terrorism

A third thing is the general Terrorism Terrorism boston marathon bombing of April 15, The boston marathon bombing claimed three lives and injured above one hundred and eighty people.... CNN's Complete Coverage of the boston marathon Bombings.... Trial Date Set for Accused boston marathon Bomber.... CNN News Room, april 15, 2013.... A third thing is the general plan that included where the criminals hid from security and put together all that they needed to carry out the bombing....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Case study identifying and assessing the analytical failures

There were a number of events which occurred during the boston marathon bombing from which the causes and impact of analytical failure can be broken down and reviewed.... The purpose of this paper is to analyze the causes of boston marathon bombing and the impact it has had in the On April 15, 2013 there were bombings near the finish line of the Boston Marathon.... One of the brothers, Tamerlan Tsarnaev, was killed when a car ran over him after struggling with police while the other brother escaped and was later apprehended....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Mobil-Marathon case

marathon Oil Company was a legal tussle that portrayed the application of some of the antitrust laws in the United States.... In October of 1981, Mobil Corporation declared its interest in purchasing shares of marathon Oil… The nature and scale of the intended purchase would result in a merger between the two companies.... The Directors of marathon Oil Company considered the proposal and refused.... They initiated a number of defensive tactics to refuse Mobil's offer including an antitrust suit The Directors of marathon Oil Company filed an antitrust suit against Mobil at United States District Court in the Northern Ohio District....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Psychological Analysis of the Boston Marathon Bomber

He was hurt by the system the most and resorted to retaliating through bombing the Boston Marathon hence following the advice by Malcolm X who advocated for retaliating against the system through violence.... This paper "Psychological Analysis of the boston marathon Bomber" focuses on the fact that the bomber was coming from a dysfunctional family with his father having left the family in 2010 and gone to live in Russia, the parents divorcing and the mother also living in Russia....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us