StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Kelo v New London Decision - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Kelo v New London Decision" discusses that it is essential to state that the city of New London located in southeastern Connecticut proposed a new plan for the development of the city when it was facing economic problems and unemployment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
The Kelo v New London Decision
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Kelo v New London Decision"

When the homeowners decided not to sell, it became imminent that the homeowners will be dispossessed of their possession as the state would implement eminent domain. This led to the filing of the suit in the Superior Court of Connecticut by the homeowners, an appeal was preferred to the Supreme Court of Connecticut and the case was finally disposed of by the US Supreme Court, taking a period of 5 years, from the year 2000 to 2005 (Kelo v. New London).

1C. The first and most important argument by the homeowners was that the cities adoption of eminent domain would violet the limitation of “Public use” in the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution. The second argument was that it blurs the boundary between private and public takings or in other words it meant that government takings may not result in the welfare of private parties. The third argument was in order to have such takings, there should be a certainty that the expected public benefits will take place (Kelo v. New London).

1D. The Amendment Fifteen to the United States Constitution states that takings could be allowed only when they were made for “public use” and “just compensation” is paid, not otherwise (Madueno 809).

1E. The Supreme Court ruled in support of the City of New London and supported the rule established by Berman v. parker, which is when the plan serves a public purpose it satisfies the public use requirement of the Fifth Amendment. The Supreme Court cited the precedent of Berman v. Parker (1954) in making its ruling (Kelo v. New London).

1F. It is the job of the legislature to limit takings, due to the fact that laws passed by the legislature can limit the takings. An example would be the Taking Clause of the US Constitution.

  1. As stated and experienced by some visitors to Detroit, who also happen to be writers, the people of Detroit live ordinary American lives amidst a landscape that is filled with burned-out homes, factories and schools. Even popular neighborhoods have evacuated homes, while some blocks are miniature ghost towns. In some areas trees, tall grasses have recaptured that which was manmade (McGraw). Despite being only a part of the total problems faced by Detroit, it is indisputable that Detroit needs change, as Ruff states, “We need radically a new vision of Detroit: the city becomes the world’s greatest bio-urban club, which can be brought into effect only through eminent domain.

Having a more convincing approach like that of Mayor Dave Bing, that is “people will not be forced from their homes as the city is reshaped”, but people will be lured by safer streets and modern services, will be of some help doing the work of development without disputes but he also agrees to say, “I am not naive” and “We are asking people who have lived here for generations to change” (Muller). Surely, he means by those words that many people are not going to agree to it and this is the specific reason why eminent domain should be adopted. The primary reason for such a decision is looking at the interest of the public.

Moreover, it is worthwhile to determine what the homeowners lost? Other than the factor, they have to leave a place where they have been for long; there is nothing else to be lost. They will be getting the price of their land and also a guarantee of a bright future in the same place they were staying in near future.

  1. As one of the VP of the Detroit Red Wings, taking a decision to relocate the business in the city of Detroit would require consideration of some vital issues, which will be focusing on the difficulties with redevelopment in Michigan and finally taking a position on the States domain law. Detroit is filled with vacant land, which consists of hundreds of geographically separate private parcels and negotiating the purchase of each plot will be logically impossible, without eminent domain. In order to relocate the business a single large piece of land would be required, which will be hard to obtain considering issues like relocating many homeowners, tacking issues of exorbitant rates and owners who refuse to sell. Moreover, a few holdouts may end a project (Moghk). In the present circumstances, relocating the business will not be possible unless and until laws relating to eminent domain are strengthened and enforced in exceptional circumstances, such as that of the city of Detroit.
Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Kelo v. New London Decision What Did the Supreme Court Hold What Assignment”, n.d.)
The Kelo v. New London Decision What Did the Supreme Court Hold What Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1581082-the-kelo-v-new-london-decision-what-did-the-supreme-court-hold-what-are-the-implications-for-economic-redevelopment-in-the-us-example-detroit
(The Kelo V. New London Decision What Did the Supreme Court Hold What Assignment)
The Kelo V. New London Decision What Did the Supreme Court Hold What Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1581082-the-kelo-v-new-london-decision-what-did-the-supreme-court-hold-what-are-the-implications-for-economic-redevelopment-in-the-us-example-detroit.
“The Kelo V. New London Decision What Did the Supreme Court Hold What Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1581082-the-kelo-v-new-london-decision-what-did-the-supreme-court-hold-what-are-the-implications-for-economic-redevelopment-in-the-us-example-detroit.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Kelo v New London Decision

The Adverse Impact of Activist Judges on the American Political System

The City of new london (Name) (University) The Adverse Impact of Activist Judges on the American Political System: Kelo v.... The City of new london One of the most controversial cases that were decided by activist judges in the United States was the case Kelo v.... The City of new london, wherein in 2005, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that local governments may actually force property owners to sell out their property and make way for private economic development projects as long as officials decide it would benefit the public, even though the success of this economic project is unsure, and the property is not blighted....
1 Pages (250 words) Personal Statement

Transmission Lines Easements and Personal Property

City of new london, U.... Supreme Court happened from the fact of censure by new london, Connecticut of privately owned real estate so that it could be employed as part of a wider redevelopment scheme.... In the historical decision in kelo v.... Supreme Court held in kelo v.... he above decision by the U.... In a 5-4 decision, U.... City of new London1, that the employment of eminent domain to convey rights of land from one private owner to another one for the furtherance of the economic development....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Eminent Domain Assignment

Ryskamp gives a report on the law and politics of eminent domain after the decision of the Supreme Court on the case of Kelo versus the city of new london on June 2005.... Among the cases or legal briefs covered in this book is the case of Kelo versus the city of new london.... The discussion is centered on the recent ruling of the US Supreme Court on the case of Kelov versus the city of new london (2005).... The Eminent Domain Revolt: Changing Perceptions in a new Constitutional Epoch....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

SUPREME COURT CASE

City of new london, 2005, 5-4.... City of new london concerned the power of government(s) to force the sale of private property if it falls within the eminent domain.... of new london, 2005, 5-4.... of new london concerned the power of government(s) to force the sale of private property if it falls within the eminent domain.... The City of new london, Connecticut sought to force the sale of some private property to be used for an urban redevelopment project....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Constitutional Law: Eminent Domain

The owner can withdraw that amount and can still demand more compensation (Szypszak) and (Kelo v City of new london).... In this paper, it is proposed to examine State‘s power of eminent domain in the light of the recent decision of the U.... Constitutional Law: Eminent Domain Introduction In relation to property rights and responsibilities, constitutional crisis at times crops up....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Laws on Property Critical Analysis

City of new london (2005) was a case where the owners of real property filed suit against new london for expropriating their land in alleged violation of the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution which guarantees expropriations shall be made only for public use and upon just compensation.... The Court held that the City as a whole would benefit because the development would bring much-needed capital, investments and work to the City of new london which is in dire need of an economic uplift....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Eminent Domain Law in California

City of new london The decision by the U.... It was noted by the California Senate Local Government Committee that there was a similarity between eminent domain use in California and new london, Connecticut.... Implications of kelo v.... Because of public concern about the possibility of rent control being phased out and the fact that both propositions were efforts to amend Article I, of the California State Constitution, the California voters made the decision to reject the proposition....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

99 Cent V. Lancaster Redevelopment

the kelo v.... City of new london, the result of the 99 Cent Only case would quite likely be different.... City of new london case was similar to the 99 Cent Only Stores v.... Lancaster Redevelopment Agency case in that new london was trying to obtain property in order to help a profitable company expand.... What made this case different, though, was the way that the City of new london manipulated the Fifth Amendment....
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us