StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Prison Camps of the Civil War - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The researcher of this essay will begin with the statement that the Civil War prison camps at Camp Sumter (also known as Andersonville) and Elmira bear the distinction of having been the two worst internment facilities in the conflict between the states. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Prison Camps of the Civil War
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Prison Camps of the Civil War"

A SENTENCE OF DEATH: APATHY AND NEGLECT AT ELMIRA AND CAMP SUMTER TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………….1 2. ORGANIZATION AND ADMINISTRATION………………………………....2 3. MEDICAL FACILITIES…………………….…………………………………..4 4. PHYSICAL CONDITIONS……………………………………………………...5 5. CONCLUSION…………………………………………………………………...6 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION The Civil War prison camps at Camp Sumter (also known as Andersonville) and Elmira bear the distinction of having been the two worst internment facilities in the conflict between the states. Both were products of neglect and of the circumstances of war, which dictated that both sides devote resources to their own troops rather than to enemy soldiers, prisoners though they were. Logistical concerns were among the most problematic during the Civil War. Armies in the field commonly suffered from deprivation, from shortages of materiel, ammunition and proper clothing. As such, the Federal and Confederate governments were too concerned with overcoming these problems to pay sufficient heed to housing and caring for prisoners. But there was something uglier at work in the neglect both sides exhibited. Propaganda and a human desire for revenge manifested itself against the helpless prisoners at Andersonville as well as Elmira, where “Secretary of War E.M. Stanton ordered Northern prison authorities to reduce food, fuel, shelter, and clothing of prisoners to levels which he and the propagandists of the North contended were parallel to conditions in the South.”1 Much has been written of the primitive nature of medicine during the Civil War. Soldiers in both armies died in the hundreds of thousands from illness and infection – the situation was exponentially worse in prison camps, where medical care was virtually non-existent. Government policy regarding prisoners also worsened an already desperate situation. Union authorities refused to continue the practice of prisoner exchange late in the war, eliminating the possibility that the burgeoning populations at Elmira and Andersonville might be reduced through attrition. For all intents and purpose, prisoners of war sent to these camps were 2 delivered up to death as surely as were those soldiers Burnside sent against Lee’s defenses at Fredericksburg, or the men of Pickett’s division who were mowed down in droves at Gettysburg. CHAPTER 2: ORGANIZATION AND ADMINISTRATION Ultimately, a lack of organization on both sides was to blame for the disasters at Elmira and Andersonville. North and South were far too committed to victory on the battlefield to devote time, personnel or even thought to their prison camps. “Neither North nor South had such a surplus of talent that it could spare first-class soldiers or administrators for prison duties.”2 Careful planning was not in evidence on either side; indeed, both were guilty of reacting to situations that were usually already out of control. With minimal government administrative controls in place, it fell to doctors to manage affairs as best they could. Unfortunately, medical professionals on both sides proved poorly qualified to manage logistics as well as discharge their surgical duties. “Either because of failure to understand the regulations (which were often poorly explained, if at all), or from frustration with petty record keeping, doctors violated protocol. As a result, they were censured for not properly filling out forms for improperly using the hospital fund, and for eating food intended for patients.”3 At both Elmira and Andersonville, this was a blueprint for disaster. In the case of the Confederacy, most prisoners were crowded into fetid camps at Richmond until 1863, when facilities in Alabama and the Carolinas were officially opened. Nevertheless, these facilities were insufficient to handle the tens of thousands of Union prisoners. By 1864, when Camp Sumter was opened, the Confederacy’s strained resources were 3 near the breaking point, with little in the way of food or medical resources available to send to prison camps. When Union prisoners arrived at Andersonville, they found that “There was no shelter from the sun and rain. There were no bathrooms…men used their blankets and overcoats to make little tents.”4 When the weather turned hot in southern Georgia, the bad conditions at Andersonville took a turn for the worse. “Weather getting warmer, water warmer and nastier, food worse and less in quantities, and more prisoners coming nearly every day,” wrote Union prisoner John L. Ransom.5 Elmira, though housing a smaller population than Camp Sumter, was as strained and unprepared for the sheer volume of prisoners it housed. As the North’s victories mounted, the numbers of Confederate prisoners grew apace. By late 1864, Elmira held nearly 10,000 Confederate prisoners of war in a facility built to accommodate roughly half that amount. It would eventually top out at more than 12,000. Much of the increase was due to the refusal of Secretary of War Edwin Stanton to engage in any further exchange of prisoners; consequently, more than 5,100 new prisoners remained at Elmira, adding to the 4,400 already interned there.6 Problems with the contractor hired to build the barracks led to chronic shortages of housing and cooking facilities. An outbreak of scurvy soon resulted. “The vitamin deficiency caused assorted spots and irritations on the body, but was principally remembered, as one victim from Elmira put it, for the way it ‘attacked the mouths and gums, becoming so spongy and sore that 4 portions could be removed with the fingers.’”7 There existed a curious symbiosis between Elmira and Andersonville: the Confederate prisoners at Elmira suffered from Northern repercussions when news of conditions at Andersonville reached Washington. Secretary Stanton’s form of reprisal was to curtail rations, medicine and other desperately needed supplies. CHAPTER 3: MEDICAL FACILITIES In July 1864, a Union medical officer named Henry Hubbard was placed in charge of a ward in the Andersonville camp hospital. With a badly deficient medical staff on hand, the Confederates pressed Hubbard into service to help handle the flow of wounded in the days after the Battle of Atlanta. Hubbard’s firsthand account of his experiences stands as one of the most harrowing reports on the state of medical care in the Civil War. He writes bitterly about both the lack of basic supplies and the indifference of the camp officials. Hubbard was stationed in an enclosed field south of the main stockade, where he found “no bedding, no clothing, no bandages, no medicine and but little food. Many undressed wounds were fly-blown and swarming with maggots. This the Confederate surgeons said was good for the wounds – assisting nature in the removal of effete matter, I suppose. But the prisoners disliked being eaten by worms before death…”8 Hubbard recounts that out of approximately 40,000 prisoners at Andersonville in late 1864, roughly one-third died due to such conditions. Medicine and hospital care were also subjects of terrible neglect at Elmira. Both sides were guilty of not being prepared to treat prisoners suffering from gunshot or shrapnel wounds 5 (which were common enough among new prisoners), to say nothing of disease and malnutrition. In the North, where resources were more plentiful, it approached the criminal, retribution or no. In the beginning, the wounded and sick at Elmira couldn’t be treated at all. “At first the prison had no hospital. Even after one was constructed there were not enough beds for the patients. The prison had no chief surgeon until after the camp had been open for a month. One of the major sources of disease at Elmira was Foster’s Pond, a large stagnant pool filled with filth, which polluted the drinking water and caused many intestinal diseases.”9 The two officers who commanded at Elmira, Seth Eastman and Benjamin Tracy, were inflexible when it came to following orders and showed no sympathy for the prisoners or concern over the squalid conditions. It is hardly surprising that Elmira had the highest rate of smallpox cases among federal prison camps (Andersonville had the highest rate among Confederate camps). CHAPTER 4: PHYSICAL CONDITIONS Elmira and Andersonville exhibited similarities and differences in terms of dimension, construction and layout. As the South’s largest prison camp, Andersonville was slightly larger than Elmira. By mid-1864, it encompassed more than 26 acres and was surrounded by a 15-foot-high stockade fence that measured 1,620 feet long by 779 feet wide. There was also an inner fence that served as a barrier that prisoners were forbidden to cross. The main water supply came from a stream called Stockade Creek, which the prisoners were forced to use for drinking, washing and toilet purposes. The site of the Elmira camp was comparable to Andersonville in size and to some extent in layout, but its location was probably even worse than its counterpart in Georgia. Part of the former Union military installation called Camp Rathbun, 6 Elmira was situated below the level of the nearby Chemung River, which flooded in March 1865, adding immeasurably to the suffering of the prisoners. After rising more than three feet above flood stage, it began to inundate the camp. Unfortunately for the prisoners, the river’s rising coincided with the latter stages of a smallpox epidemic. One Confederate prisoner gave a particularly colorful account of what he witnessed. “We had a flood while I was there, from snow melting in the mountains. It made us climb to the second bunk like possums. I saw the Yankees sail through our wards on little skiffs, in at one door and out at the other.”10 Area businesses in the Elmira community benefited somewhat from construction of the camp, for which the government contracted for construction, heating supplies and food. The situation at Andersonville was far different, and reflects the fundamental economic differences between North and South. Slaves and Confederate soldiers were put to work constructing the camp beginning in January 1864, a task that took about six weeks.11 However, only three sides of the compound wall had been completed by the time prisoners began arriving. CHAPTER FIVE: CONCLUSION As the two most notorious prison camps of the Civil War, Elmira and Andersonville exhibited many of the same harrowing physical and functional similarities. Both failed criminally in providing basic human necessities of shelter, food, water, clothing and medical care. Prisoners in both camps suffered cruelly from the non-exchange policy the Union put into effect in late 1864 to bring the war to a speedy conclusion. The two facilities differed in terms of prisoner populations and in the fact that the federal government had more money and resources 7 available (though much of this was purposely withheld). Perhaps the most interesting difference between the two is shown in the circumstances by which they were built and maintained. Slave labor was central to the construction of Andersonville, while Elmira was the product of capitalistic endeavors in the form of army contracts. Significantly, this fundamental democratic principle was the one the Union was fighting so hard and at such cost to preserve throughout the entire nation. BIBLIOGRAPHY Primary Sources: Holmes, Clayton W. The Elmira Prison Camp: A History of the Military Prison at Elmira, N.Y. New York, NY: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1912. Hubbard, Capt. H.R. Andersonville Hospital Conditions. Mendon, IL: The Mendon Dispatch, 3 March 1904. Ransom, John L. Andersonville Diary – With List of the Dead. Secondary Sources: Hesseltine, William B. Civil War Prisons. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1962. Schroeder-Lein, Glenna R. The Encyclopedia of Civil War Medicine. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc., 2008. Wade, Linda R. Prison Camps of the Civil War. Edna, MN: Abdo Publishing Co., 1998. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Prison Camps of the Civil War Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Prison Camps of the Civil War Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1752164-what-were-some-of-the-similarities-and-differences-in-the-civil-war-prison-camps-ft-sumter-and-elmira
(Prison Camps of the Civil War Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Prison Camps of the Civil War Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1752164-what-were-some-of-the-similarities-and-differences-in-the-civil-war-prison-camps-ft-sumter-and-elmira.
“Prison Camps of the Civil War Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1752164-what-were-some-of-the-similarities-and-differences-in-the-civil-war-prison-camps-ft-sumter-and-elmira.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Prison Camps of the Civil War

Resulting in the Relocation of Japanese Americans

The order instructed all military units to imprison all Japanese Americans in preselected military prison camps (http://www.... As proof that the military zones are prison camps, the Japanese were restricted to only moving within the military zones... hellip; war time entails implementing drastic measures.... The title of the document is Authorizing The Secretary of war to Prescribe Military Areas.... The United States war enemies of 1942 included Japan, Italy, and Germany....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

If Barack Obama Was Assasinated

The racism that would spring up around the assassination of Obama would be absolute, and could thrust the United States into even a possible second civil war, again fueled by racial tensions.... hellip; There is strong evidence that this event would cause a rebirth in the civil rights movement, racism would take a new life in America, and that we would then have to suffer for four more years under a daunting Republican government. The last point is probably the easiest to prove and one of the most likely to happen....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Andersonville: The Last Depot

The author's viewpoint and also some people believed that the primary reason of the overpopulation in Camp Anderson is the Union's decision to stop exchanging prisoners as they have many reserved armies and are willing to sacrifice their captured soldiers until the civil war is through.... Just for an overview about the American civil war, it is a clash between the United States of America which they call "Union" led by Abraham Lincoln and the Confederate States of America consisting of eleven states led by Jefferson Davis in the years 1860 to 1865....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Rape of women as a weapon of war

civil war general William Tecumseh Sherman pioneered total war in 1846.... In Bosnia, the Serbian camps are attempting to make it a Serbian state by impregnating Muslim mothers with Serb babies.... This method is a sadistic form of genocide, a method widespread among numerous countries, more dangerous and probably more damaging than a bullet through your body....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Gathering Storm and Global War

Japanese prison camps should have been given $20,000 in reparations, not only for their economic and material losses but also for the emotional turmoil at the loss of security of being an American citizen.... Japanese prison camps were not only a mistake but wrong as well.... If the atomic bomb had not been used, the war could have lasted indefinitely....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process

ince at least the civil war there has been a hangover from wartime strategy that has infected the democratic process in the aftermath of war.... The US has sacrificed the democratic process in times of war in order to pursue a strategy that was deemed necessary and effective at the time.... hellip; According to the report, the executive branch and the military expanding the war into Cambodia with neither the knowledge nor the support of Congress, was a clear violation of the democratic process....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Colleges Flunk Fair Admission

The Second Chance Act of 2008 and Opportunity and Affordability Act of 2007 for educating people in prison, are good to start with but many federal laws need to be modified as they hinder educational and employment opportunities for persons with a scandalous background.... If the doors of education are open to people in prison how you can close the same when these people are in the outside world....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The Battle of Perryville and Company Aytch

In an American Civil war; the Battle of Perryville, that took place on 8th October 1862, is believed to have been the epitome of the civil wars that took place in the America during the 18th century, over the course of the war three million soldiers which consisted a few women… served as soldiers as compared to sixteen thousand soldiers that served the US army before the civil wars, by the end of the war that left a very large number of casualties almost six hundred and twenty men succumbed to death this was especially due to unpreparedness and poor aining of the soldiers in the face of the new technology in the field of war, this left horrific and devastating experiences to many people and influenced many young men to volunteer to fight through different companies, among them was Sam R....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us