StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Exploring Original Intent versus Living Constitution (20.09.11) Original intent is a legal and constitutional process by which the constitution is legally interpreted in seeking to ascertain the original meanings of specific provisions of the federal or state constitution by determining the ways in which the given provisions were perceived when the constitution was drafted and ratified…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution"

Download file to see previous pages

For people that propagate approaches towards original intent, the very essence of ideas pertaining to the rule of law can be found by searching for the original intention in the constitution. This original intention is the very basis for differentiating between the acts of judging from the acts of legislating. Judges are bound to give rulings on the basis of what was intended by the constitution in terms of the given words. However, a large number of controversies have arisen regarding original intent in terms of the power with the Supreme Court as granted by the US Constitution.

Hence, while deciding constitutional matters, the issue has often arisen whether the Supreme Court should abide by the original intent or should make attempts to interpret the Constitution in keeping with the present times. The question also arises whether the original intent was intended by the framers of the Constitution to always remain the original intent. People defending original intent hold that if judges are given a free hand in not entirely complying with the Constitution they will themselves become lawmakers.

Thus it is important for judges to keep up with the Constitution instead of attempting to keep up the Constitution with present times (William, 1976). This is how the significance of original intent is determined in the present times, despite the far reaching changes that have taken place in society and value systems since the Constitution was written. The US constitution is not very lengthy and does not provide explanations or solutions for every situation. Moreover, even in circumstances that appear to be clear, conflicting rights and conflicting areas of authority and power come to the surface.

It is in situations like this, when disputes arise and judges have to make interpretations of the Constitution. The constitutions of many countries are very rigid and provide for the judiciary to strictly follow its provisions, although adaptations are made sometimes in keeping with changes in technology, public opinion, political viewpoints and governments. However, the Constitution of the US has been described as a Living Constitution, partly because it can grow and be adapted to internal and external influences in being changed from one period and generation to another.

All judges are not known to fully comply with the concept of original content and most do not adhere to it faithfully and uniformly. Judges attempting to use the judicial philosophy of original content are in agreement that only by applying it can courts be bound by the law instead of their own viewpoints on what is desirable. These judges believe that original content should be applied in order to conserve the spirit of democracy put forth by the Constitution. However, modernists hold that the Constitution has been purposely left vague in several areas, primarily to allow modern interpretation to supersede the old ideas as the Constitution becomes older.

This is the interpretation and perception that represents the concept of the Living Constitution. It is held that the Constitution is quite flexible and has been changing the belief and values systems of people. As such, modernists do not deny the importance of originalism because they agree the historical perspective of the Constitution does have immense value. But they argue that the present needs of society are far more important than just adhering to

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1431944-exploring-original-intent-v-a-living-constitution
(Exploring Original Intent Versus a Living Constitution Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1431944-exploring-original-intent-v-a-living-constitution.
“Exploring Original Intent Versus a Living Constitution Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1431944-exploring-original-intent-v-a-living-constitution.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution

Invasion of Privacy

Running Head: INVASION OF PRIVACY Name of student: Title: Invasion of privacy Lecturer: University: Introduction Every person has the right to privacy, which cannot and should not be compromised without the authority of the courts or in a situation whereby the right conflicts with other fundamental rights enshrined in the constitution (Alderman, 2001).... However, it is observable that the US constitution, through the 9th amendment, offer a blank check to the courts enabling them protect human rights that are not included in the constitution (Kennedy, 2003)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Sentence of Death for Those Who Do Not Kill

In the article “Executing Those Who Do Not Kill: A Categorical Approach to Proportional Sentencing”, by Joseph Trigilio and Tracy Casadio, we are asked to examine the historical and current policies of the United States Supreme Court in regards to those who are only accomplices in felony cases, cases in which they did not kill or intend to kill, with regards to the view on the sentence of capital punishment, especially given the criteria that the death penalty may be viewed as “cruel and unusual punishment” as per the United States constitution, Amendment VIII....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Should Illegal Emigrants Go Back to Their Countries

The settlement of racial disputes and embracing the principles set forth in the constitution of the United States later idealized kinship by blood or culture in a foreign land as part of the new and distinct civilization of the United States.... The constant lure and appeal of living in highly urbanized and free nation has allowed mass immigration and promised unlimited opportunity that other countries failed to provide....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Immigration: 1900- Dream Act

The present study aims to explore the history of the legislation made by the US political authorities, related to immigration policies and strategies, from the beginning of twentieth century onward, by providing a brief overview of immigration laws introduced since its… The legislation was frequently executed and implemented at federal and state levels in the wake of the consecutive flow of immigration witnessed by the populations belonging to diverse geographical zones and regions of the globe to the Unites States of America One of the most striking reasons behind exploring the immigration phenomenon includes the tremendous developments observed by the USA during the recent past with regards to arrival of the foreigners from various ethnic, racial, religious, social, cultural and economic backgrounds en mass as US immigrants; which not only has resulted into noteworthy alterations in the demographical statistics of the country, but has also created serious problems for both the US citizens and recently arrived immigrants....
50 Pages (12500 words) Thesis

The Importance of Cultural Differences in the Society and Its Impact on Every Field of the Society

This happens because the concept of individualism in the USA obscures the importance of culture in the self-constitution phase.... One needs to mould their activities and personalities according to the place where they are living in.... This paper describes the importance of cultural differences in the society and its impact on each and every field of the society from day to day tasks to operational decisions, from achieving and focusing on the short-term goals to the long-term commitments....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

NSA's Phone and Internet Surveillance

However, the constitution of the United States provides ample protections and guarantees for avoiding liberty violations and human rights violations which are intended to oppress virtually unlimited powers by the executive branch of the country.... "NSA Phone and Internet Surveillance: An Issue Attempting to Balance Security, Liberty, and Human Rights" paper examines the conceptions of liberty and established laws that support phone and Internet surveillance to determine whether such legislation violates the supposedly inalienable guarantee....
20 Pages (5000 words) Coursework

The Important Aspects of the Australian Culture

This paper looks at some of the most important aspects of the Australian culture.... the author concludes that  Australian geography, history, the culture of the people, and its contribution of its people to important aspects of the world such as cuisines, films, theater, and music are immense … The history of performing arts is what is known as a theater in Australia....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The Anthropology of Crime and Violence

The object of analysis for the purpose of this paper "The Anthropology of Crime and Violence" is violence is inherent within everyday life.... Consequently, defining nationalism, without presenting an act of violence that comes with it, is difficult in the present day.... hellip; Nationalism has been stereotyped with acts of excessive violence....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us