StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Instructor name Date Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary Random drug testing of employees and job applicants began during the “just say no” era of the 1980’s when the Reagan administration amped up the failed “war on drugs” that began in the early 1970’s by the President Nixon…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary"

Download file to see previous pages

Employees are required to prove their innocence while showing no outward signs of using illegal drugs. Many would say that violates not only the U.S. Constitution but the precepts of any free society. A more egregious example of an overzealous drug policy is the recent growing trend to require welfare recipients, residents of public housing and other forms of public assistance to be tested for drugs prior to receiving assistance. These policies do not save money or lower the rate of drug use.

What they do is oppress and humiliate the most vulnerable of society, the poor and minorities, and constitute a considerable and unwarranted invasion of privacy. At the heart of this passionate political debate are demeaning and inaccurate portrayals of people who “typically” receive welfare, characterizations that are not supported by evidence. One such stereotype is of the drug or alcohol addicted “welfare queen” who continues to bear children so the amount of her assistance checks increase and she can buy more drugs.

Drug testing the poor is unquestionable popular among voters due to the prevailing yet misinformed opinion that the poor are lazy and undeserving of government help, “why should I work to pay for ‘them’ to sit at home all day?” is a commonly heard phrase. . The facts, however, mirror this perception. Laws meant to purge the system from “drug abusing welfare cheats” do not accomplish what they are intended to do and are most likely unconstitutional. For example, drug testing people on welfare is supposed to save money, that’s the main argument.

The 2008 Great Recession caused a great financial hardship to individuals as well as all levels of government. Saving money by eliminating waste is a popular political stance but the money saved is relatively small amount and is often exceeded by the cost to implement the testing law. “Idaho recently commissioned a study of the likely financial impact of drug testing its welfare applicants. The study found that the costs were likely to exceed any money saved.” (Cohen, 2012). An extensive peer-reviewed study found that a only a small minority of public assistance programs recipients such as Medicaid, food stamps, WIC AFDC and SSI, contrary to common opinion, have drug and alcohol problems, about five percent abuse drugs and six percent have an alcohol dependency.

(Grant, Dawson, 1996.) A report from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism confirmed several other studies which found welfare recipients do not use or abuse drugs or alcohol at a rate higher than the general population. A separate study discovered that nearly three-quarters of adult drug users are have full time jobs. The arguments for drug testing welfare recipients do not square with the facts or the reality of the situation but the laws are politically popular due to the broadly help belief that the poor deserve unequal status and should be punished by society for their financial circumstance.

This society would

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary Essay”, n.d.)
Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1452227-random-drug-testing-for-welfare-recipients
(Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Is Illegal and Unnecessary Essay)
Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Is Illegal and Unnecessary Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1452227-random-drug-testing-for-welfare-recipients.
“Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Is Illegal and Unnecessary Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1452227-random-drug-testing-for-welfare-recipients.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients is Illegal and Unnecessary

Should Welfare Recipients Submit to Drug Testing

It is evident that the use of drugs in the US is illegal.... SHOULD welfare recipients SUBMIT TO DRUG TESTING?... There are several critics who claim that, by doing drug testing, the state will be interfering with an individual's privacy.... drug testing policy has already been passed in some States including Florida, and at least 10% of its employees are tested in every three months.... Name Institution Assignment 1 (80 Points) Definition of welfare These are programs run by the government which makes sure that all citizens are comfortable, especially those who are low income earners....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

National Conference of State Legislatures

The driving force, however, for this issue is considered to be perception towards the less fortunate people who are welfare recipients that they are drug abusers.... This essay sheds light on the both sides of argument and how those in favor and those against the legislation of drug testing welfare recipients have put forward their respective points.... Since government can be seen as an employer of welfare recipients in this case, this shouldn't be contrary to the law and constitution....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Should drug tests be mandatory for welfare

drug testing for welfare applicants is a way of stigmatizing the needy.... Drug tests should not be mandatory for welfare; people should not be forced to go through drug test to access the welfare benefits.... On the contrary, passing such laws that require drug tests for welfare would means that all welfare applicants are guilty, and that they have to prove their innocence.... Why drug tests be made mandatory for welfare applicants, and yet there so many other government programs that do not require drug tests?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

UN Protection of Human Rights: Africa and Aids

In this principle the UN recognises that every person regardless of where they live is entitled to quality health care, current treatment methods, preventative supplies, counselling and testing.... At the First International Consultation of HIV/AIDS and Human Rights in July of 1989 the United Nations (UN) proposed to set guidelines for policy and practice in the treatment of people infected with HIV/AIDS to ensure compliance with all international law....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Ethics, Fraud and Abuse in Health Care

Traditional healthcare ethics demonstrates various characteristics of professionals in healthcare industry such as welfare of patients, advanced medical knowledge, compassionate approach towards the patients, and reliable financial dealings.... This paper seeks to explore the ethical principles that govern health care practices and in doing so the paper throws light on the fraud and abuse that prevail in the health care industry....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Slippery Slope and related Hypothesis

Deviance in public service and policing can be attributed to various causes.... The purpose of this paper "Slippery Slope and related Hypothesis" is to describe the slippery slope theory and represent a discussion about thoughts on the theory from different perspectives.... hellip; The slippery slope theory claims that a minor step that is taken at first is likely to result to a number of effects either immediately, with time or in future....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Public Policy Issue: Drug Testing Welfare Recipients

An author of the present writing "Public Policy Issue: Drug Testing Welfare Recipients" will examine the current situation with the relevancy of drug tests for welfare recipients.... Over the years, drug abusers have benefited from welfare programs provided by the government.... This issue has been witnessed widely to the extent of these individuals referred to with names such as welfare queens (Sulzberger 1).... The name depicts the protection welfare has put on drug fiends and the irresponsible nature of individuals receiving government assistance....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Should Welfare Recipients be Drug Tested to Receive Government Aid

To support the point, Garth Everett, a Republic who defended drug testing legislation said that concern for drug test grew out of bitterness that the workers in many industries are tested for drugs several times, whereas welfare recipients are never subject to any such tests despite a high possibility of drug abuse.... According to them, this shouldn't be contrary to the statute and constitution as a government can be seen as an employer of welfare recipients in this case (Hall, 2012)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us