StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Comparison of ender and Pheidippides - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Prof’s Name Date Challenging, Generating New Principles and the Coercive Education: Similarities between Orson Scott Card’s “Ender” and Aristophanes’ “Pheidippides” Education is one of the central discussions of literature: nearly every author or playwright had to go through an education of some kind, so many choose to reflect on their experience…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Comparison of ender and Pheidippides
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of ender and Pheidippides"

Download file to see previous pages

They both entered highly rigorous educational institutions designed to shape them permanently, for instance, and both characters seem to engage with their educators in somewhat similar ways. Furthermore, both characters entered their educational institutions for reasons other than self-betterment, and under pressure from outside sources. Ender and Pheidippides both demonstrate two important qualities in students: the willingness to challenge their teachers, the willingness to ‘buy in’ to their educational systems, but both also show very clearly that a coercive education is damaging and that one must have the right reasons for seeking education.

One thing that becomes clear immediately about both Ender and Pheidippides is that neither is simply willing to accept what their instructors say; rather, both show a willingness to challenge their instructors or superiors in cases that do not make sense. Early upon joining real battles in Battle School, Ender is told by his superior: you will not pass through the gate until four full minutes after the beginning of the game, and then you will remain at the gate, with your weapon undrawn and unfired, until such time as the game ends (Card 87), which obviously puts his teammates at a disadvantage, being down one person.

He refuses, however, to obey. Eventually, he sits lifeless through an entire battle, only to force a draw at the final moments by going against order and attacking his opponents by surprise (94), and winning the game. He suffers punishment for his actions, but learns that sometimes disobeying a superior is the right thing – and that instructors do not necessarily know everything. Pheidippides shows a similar willingness to challenge his teacher’s instructions. In “The Clouds” the audience does not see a great deal of Pheidippides’ education, other than a brief exchange between the two arguments, and the experience of his father.

Pheidippides’ shows he is willing to question his teacher by arguing against the things his father learned during his time in the Thinkery. The father, for instance, insists that two different things cannot both be a “fowl” (Aristophones 1080) This essentially negates the categorization of objects, but is not something that Pheidippides is willing to accept on face value: he challenges his father, arguing that this does not constitute an education (1084). Both Ender and Pheidippides are willing to question the educations they are given.

Though both characters certainly seem willing to question their educations, they both also buy in to their educations. Though Ender initially hates his educational experience, his isolation and so on, when he is put in the role of an educator he in fact repeats the very isolating acts he hated one of his students, Bean. He singles the boy out, making the others “avoid eye-contact with him” (Card 134), exactly as he had done to him. Though he “wanted to undo his taunting of the boy” (134), he in fact continues the isolating practices picking the boy out again by saying “Bean doesn’t think so,” when he believes the boy disagrees with what his fellows are thinking because he knows it will make the boy a better soldier, like it made him a better one.

Pheidippides shows a similar willingness to buy in to his education. He observes the arguments of “

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of ender and Pheidippides Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/english/1446492-comparison-of-ender-and-pheidippides
(Comparison of Ender and Pheidippides Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1446492-comparison-of-ender-and-pheidippides.
“Comparison of Ender and Pheidippides Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1446492-comparison-of-ender-and-pheidippides.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of ender and Pheidippides

Singaporean Humor: A Cross-Cultural, Cross-Gender Comparison

Singaporean humour: A Cross-Cultural, Cross-Gender comparison Summary of Reading In their joint venture entitled; Singaporean humour: A Cross-Cultural, Cross-Gender comparison, Ofra Nevo et al.... Authors make comparison between the reactions of Isreali and U....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Comedy: from Aristophanes to Its Contemporary Form

The comedy as theater genre developed in Athens in the early 4th century when Athens was locked in a war with Sparta.... As such this theater form may be said to have grown out of a desire to ease the tension and depression brought by that long-drawn conflict on the Athenians.... hellip; In fact, Aristophanes, whose comedies became an "important historical source of Athens of the 4th and 5th centuries," (Bates, A....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Comparison of Apples and Oranges

In this paper “Food comparison” the author seeks to compare apples and oranges and therefore creates a comparison which will be useful if ever apples and oranges need to be compared.... He refers to the comparison between apples and oranges of which many have heard about but few have made.... Compare and Contrast There is a comparison which is often considered the mother of all comparisons and the root of how comparisons are defined....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Educational effectiveness - International Comparison

Thus, understanding and analyzing all the concepts and issues behind cross-country comparison of educational effectiveness is a good approach of appreciating education.... But there is also one new yet already proven method of assessing the effectiveness of the educational system, and this is through international comparison....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Comparison/contrast

comparison Canada and the United s are two different countries, but they are easy to compare.... They share a lot of similar things, including a language and some similar geography.... Although there are differences between the people in both countries, they are more similar than different… In this assignment I will make some further comparisons between these two fine North American countries, their histories, cultures, and economies. Both of these two countries are fairly young compared to other countries....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Major Social Comparison Issues

anger, Pirson, & Delizonna (2010) illuminate that researchers studying comparison of physical attraction have been skeptical of the Social Comparison Theory.... The paper "Major Social comparison Issues" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues concerning the social comparison based both on body image and self-esteem.... Social comparison Theory provides the platform for individuals to maintain accurate self-concepts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Social Comparison Theory

However, the most important application of the social comparison theory has been on the improvement of the health conditions of patients with chronic diseases… Social comparison research has developed a lot from studies focusing on the single phenomenon on such as self-evaluation to wide studies covering the influence of emotions and behaviors.... Scholars are now studying the effects of social comparison in populations making the concept more important than a mere lab experiment Social comparison research has developed a lot from studies focusing on the single phenomenon on such as self-evaluation to wide studies covering the influence of emotions and behaviors....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Gender and Sex Comparison

The author compares the notions "gender" and "sex" and states that sex is a biological paradigm that captures the genetic, physiological, anatomical variation that presents in species and gender refers to the characteristics which a culture or society delineates as feminine or masculine… Gender has been considered to be the performance that is constructed through individual's practices....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us