StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Perspective - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Western idea of “progress” stems from the period known as “The Enlightenment” which was an age of exploration and discovery. We like to think of it as the time in which modern scientific principles were developed. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Perspective
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Perspective"

Trudyann Blackburn A Critique of the Western notions of “progress” from an anthropological perspective. Straughn- Williams SSA 101.1869 ACritique of the Western notions of “progress” from an anthropological perspective. The Western idea of “progress” stems from the period known as “The Enlightenment” which was an age of exploration and discovery. We like to think of it as the time in which modern scientific principles were developed. The industrial revolution had seen a huge rise in the population of the world, with an increasing concentration in cities.

Western nations had colonized vast areas of the globe and had begun to exploit their resources in a systematic fashion. Old subsistence level work in agriculture was replaced by labor saving machinery, and mass production of all kinds of consumer goods. Goods became cheaper, and life, for those in the West at least, was made easier. This point of view treated all of the earth’s problems as matters which could be solved by mankind’s ingenuity. In recent years this notion that humans are moving in a positive direction, improving their lives as they move from caveman status, to hunter gathering, to farming and now to industrialization has been challenged.

Jared Diamond (1994) reports these notions are widely assumed to be true but not proven. The theory that agriculture creates food surpluses, which allow people more leisure time, and thus the space to create cultural advances is just a theory, for example, and there are other possible interpretations of human history over the long term. Diamond cites the work of anthropologists with modern hunter-gatherer tribes as evidence that this lifestyle is precisely not inferior to the agricultural lifestyle: “these people (= Kalahari bushmen) … have plenty of leisure time, sleep a good deal, and work less hard than their farming neihbors” (Diamond: 1994, 106) When one adds to this the evidence of paleopathology, in which scientists work out the health and diet of prehistoric specimens, it becomes clear that agriculture may have been a poor choice, rather than a progressive one.

There are three pieces of evidence cited by anthropologists who oppose a progressive interpretation of human history: hunter gatherers ate a wider variety of different foods and a higher quality of food, than farmers; hunter gatherers did not depend on two or three food sources, and so they could survive when there was a weather disaster; and hunter gatherers moved around more, which kept them safe from diseases and epidemics (Diamond: 1994, 107) Once again there is plenty of evidence from the modern world to support these ideas since one only needs to look at the waves of famine that hit Africa and Asia year after year to realize that a dependence on core crops like rice and wheat create huge health risks for millions of people.

Even in relatively prosperous America there are problems with the reliance on agriculture and huge cities. As Striffler (2005) explains in his study on the harmful effects of mass production in the chicken industry, there are harmful effects built into every stage of mass production. From the antibiotics that are pumped into the animals to keep down infection in their overcrowded accommodation, to the decrease in diversity in the breeds that are used, everything indicated a system in a state of terminal decline.

The only way to stop this and restore human food to an acceptable and healthy standard is to return to more humane and “friendly” ways of dealing with animals. The lives of animals and farm workers alike are blighted by the pressure to produce ever more cheaply. In the modern world there are many interlocking factors such as wage rates and prices in the local, national and international markets which can affect the ability of farmers to produce food that is fit for human consumption. This means that economic as well as physical pressures weigh down the system and make it susceptible to devastating diseases and disasters.

When producers themselves are not enabled to look after the welfare of their animals, then there is little chance that those who process and sell the product further along the chain from farm to supermarket and dinner table can guarantee even minimum health standards. In the light of this, all the efficiency and scientific knowledge in the world is not able to guarantee a better lifestyle for modern citizens. In conclusion, therefore, it seems that the progressive view of human history is not proven and the reverse may indeed be true.

Hunter gatherers have survived in parts of the world where agriculture has grabbed all the best land, and they demonstrate that even when pushed to the margins, they have a healthier lifestyle, and more leisure time than the majority of farmers. When seen through the eyes of an anthropologist, the narratives of Western societies show a huge “progress” in terms of theoretical knowledge, but a huge deficit in terms of real results. It looks as if the shift from hunter gatherer to farming culture has led the world into a trap of unsustainability.

It seems that a regressive view, that recommends living on a scale and in a fashion that fits in with nature, rather than attempting to control nature and exploit every last possible calorie, would have been a far better choice than the one that the majority of mankind is forced to endure. References Diamond, J. (1994) The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race. In A. Padolefsky and P.J. Brown (Eds) Applying Cultural Anthropology: An Introductory Reader. London and Toronto: Mayfield Publishing, 105-108.

Striffler, Steve. (2005 ) Chicken The Dangerous Transformation of America’s Favourite Food. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1425077-question
(A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Essay)
https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1425077-question.
“A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1425077-question.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Critique of the Western Notions of Progress from an Anthropological Perspective

The Cultural Globalization

The spread from one region to another of different symbols, products, and concepts of culture across the globe, and their incorporation into new cultures are key to cultural globalization.... The culture was considered as that which differentiated one group from another, thereby identifying “otherness”.... However, mainly due to global technology it is increasingly possible to maintain one's ethnic identity through quick visits to home country by air, cheap and instantaneous communication with the family that stayed behind, business networks and financial transactions both ways, expatriate participation in home-country politics, and a constant introduction of new immigrants from home country contribute to sustaining migrant ethnicity for long periods and prevents homogenization with the host culture....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Assumptions Regarding Gender Oppression in the Middle East

from an overarching perspective, this reaction paper argues that traditional means of examining gender in the Middle East are biased politically and culturally.... The above argument is supported by Lazreg (1988) who further considers notions of gender within the East and West.... Abu-Lugod (2002) takes this a step further and argues that the analytical focus should not be centered on a gendered dialectic, but should instead focus on notions of human justice....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Women in Africa: An Endless Struggle

By the middle of that century, Portugal began importing slaves from African trading posts along the western coast.... Diamond even argued that the languages spoken by Arabs and Jews originated from West Africa, which explains why Jewish, Islamic and Christian communities easily took root.... However, it was not until the 15th century after Europe experienced severe labor shortages from the disastrous waves of wars, diseases and foreign colonization did Africa turn into a prime source of slave labor....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Marxism in Anthropology

What they forgot to see is the fact that alienation and labour are the central categories through which Marx delineated his critique of the social structure of bourgeois society.... Otherwise, the anthropological enquiries of Marxism cannot become a revolutionary tool in the hands of working class.... The ethnographic relativism of the real world which is fragmented into nations and regional societies could only be adequately explained through a theoretically rigorous anthropological paradigm....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sociology of Max Weber

Over the last decade, there has been a quiet revolution in the interpretation of the sociology of Max Weber.... The key to these changes has been the disappearance of the obsession with the theme of Marx versus Weber.... hellip; The gradual erosion in the importance of French Marxism over English social science paved the way for more interesting and more relevant interpretations of Weber....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Major Problems with the Evolutionist Practice of Classifying Cultures

This provides a possible perspective from which the social evolutionism theory fails to fully capture the manner in which societies are set.... While the earlier anthropologists held the view that societal development took place as a single entity, subsequent social anthropologists are of the view that this societal development is variant upon each society, with each exhibiting its own levels of developmental stages distinct from others.... Furthermore, such early anthropologists as Edward Taylor specifically relied upon information from indigenous cultures, and drew conclusions from such findings and generalizing them to the...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Concept and Practices of Development

The concept of development from an economic approach encompasses, firstly, the concept of resources that the country posses in determining its success level (Santander, 2014, p 65).... For instance, in analyzing the concepts of development from the economic perspective, various theories and approaches as well as challenges to these concepts are evident.... All these concepts emanate from the various political activism procedures, developing the concepts and procedures accordingly....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ethnicity Confers to Relationship Aspect but Not a Property of a Group

The anthropological and psychological aspects of ethnicity confirm ethnicity as a string of relationships between groups and individuals.... This coursework "Ethnicity Confers to Relationship Aspect but Not a Property of a Group" focuses on the meaning and significance of ethnicity as an essential aspect of a relationship....
18 Pages (4500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us